OT: - Best Pizza in CT | Page 123 | The Boneyard

OT: Best Pizza in CT

You weighed on Grand Apizza before. Care to refine your review after the Portnoy “expert” score?
I used to live in a house the parking lot behind there about 250 feet door to door. It’s serviceable that’s it. I stick by that. But I haven’t been there in 15 years either.
 
Gary still owns the bar, did he clean it up or something?
Anybody know why Bohemian was torn down and rebuilt in the identical footprint? I don’t think there was a fire?
 
You weighed on Grand Apizza before. Care to refine your review after the Portnoy “expert” score?
I don’t know if I weighed in on it before but I am guessing I did. We get pizza there occasionally. I think Nuzz is stretching the “big four” simply because the original was technically in New Haven, but it is Fair Haven and no one I know considers Grand Apizza on par with Sally’s, Modern or Pepe’s. It is definitely among the best of the next level though. It is very decent non-New Haven, New Haven-style pizza. Of which there are many. Thankfully.
 
.-.
Anybody know why Bohemian was torn down and rebuilt in the identical footprint? I don’t think there was a fire?
It was falling apart, roof caving in. I remember bugging Gary for work before the place even opened over 20 years ago and he would ask my friend all the time if he wanted to buy it off him. I'm glad he kept it all these years.

Gary is a good guy and has always been a character. The town didn't want him there after the notoriety from his first bar the Purple Gator in Torrington and was throwing up roadblocks for him. He turned it into a local fixture. Locals never called it Bohemian or Ditto's. It was always the Tavern or the Dirt Bar.
 
Portnoy loves CT apizza all his CT reviews have been positive.

He likes his pie really well done. He should try Papas in Milford.

I don't understand the love for Papas in Milford. That where my in laws get pizza all the time and its meh to me. I get Milford doesn't have great options but they and my wife family speak of it like it's a great pie
 
I don't understand the love for Papas in Milford. That where my in laws get pizza all the time and its meh to me. I get Milford doesn't have great options but they and my wife family speak of it like it's a great pie
Which one are you going to? The one on Naugatuck Ave. in Devon is better than the one on Bridgeport Ave. IMO.
 
I don't understand the love for Papas in Milford. That where my in laws get pizza all the time and its meh to me. I get Milford doesn't have great options but they and my wife family speak of it like it's a great pie
Which one are you going to? The one on Naugatuck Ave. in Devon is better than the one on Bridgeport Ave. IMO.
Devon.
The thing to get at Papa’s is not the pizza, but the “cone” grinders. Chicken parm cone especially.
 
.-.
The thing to get at Papa’s is not the pizza, but the “cone” grinders. Chicken parm cone especially.
IIRC, they have good coupons early in the week for those who want to make up their own mind about the pizza. Didn't strike me as something worth crossing town lines for, but not bad.
 
IIRC, they have good coupons early in the week for those who want to make up their own mind about the pizza. Didn't strike me as something worth crossing town lines for, but not bad.
Agreed. Definitely not bad. But the cones are a distinctive item and worth a trip imo. They cut off one end of a grinder roll, hollow it out, fill it with your grinder filling of choice (in my case, chicken parm, which is cubed) and then put back a bread cork of sorts on the open end and then put it in the oven to seal the cone and heat the filling. Makes for a very nice and unique grinder.

“Everybody must get coned!”
 
.-.
On my backstage toads rider tonight
 

Attachments

  • 45B67889-692C-44B4-98B3-E77E0D0A2E10.jpeg
    45B67889-692C-44B4-98B3-E77E0D0A2E10.jpeg
    712.5 KB · Views: 46
.-.
Had a chance to finally visit Bufalina yesterday. Very good pizza that I would eat regularly if I lived closer. Good crust, good char, maybe a slight bit too doughy for thin crust. They only have 7 or 8 specialty pies though and no option to build a pie with your own toppings, other than mixing and matching the toppings available on the specialty pies. Nice people and atmosphere, worth trying for sure.
 
Had a chance to finally visit Bufalina yesterday. Very good pizza that I would eat regularly if I lived closer. Good crust, good char, maybe a slight bit too doughy for thin crust. They only have 7 or 8 specialty pies though and no option to build a pie with your own toppings, other than mixing and matching the toppings available on the specialty pies. Nice people and atmosphere, worth trying for sure.
Did you get the special pie with pesto, peas, scapes, buffalo mozzarella and bacon? Had that earlier this week and thought it was excellent. Also got the fagioli (white bean purée, sausage, charred broccoli and lemon) from the new summer menu and thought it was good but not as good as the special.
 
Did you get the special pie with pesto, peas, scapes, buffalo mozzarella and bacon? Had that earlier this week and thought it was excellent. Also got the fagioli (white bean purée, sausage, charred broccoli and lemon) from the new summer menu and thought it was good but not as good as the special.
I did not but now you have me thinking I need a return trip very soon! I ordered a margherita as a starter while waiting for someone. I got surprisingly full from that and didn’t try another pie.
 
I did not but now you have me thinking I need a return trip very soon! I ordered a margherita as a starter while waiting for someone. I got surprisingly full from that and didn’t try another pie.
Scapes will probably be gone after this week. They are usually only around for a few weeks, and Bufalina usually changes their special pie by the week.

But definitely get the fichi from the summer menu. Figs, Gorgonzola dolce and speck. Tremendous.
 
Scapes will probably be gone after this week. They are usually only around for a few weeks, and Bufalina usually changes their special pie by the week.

But definitely get the fichi from the summer menu. Figs, Gorgonzola dolce and speck. Tremendous.
I was definitely eyeing the fichi!
 
Scapes will probably be gone after this week. They are usually only around for a few weeks, and Bufalina usually changes their special pie by the week.

But definitely get the fichi from the summer menu. Figs, Gorgonzola dolce and speck. Tremendous.

Made a scape pesto that I put on grilled chicken thighs last weekend. My breath still stinks.
 
.-.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,359
Messages
4,567,557
Members
10,469
Latest member
xxBlueChips


Top Bottom