Just want to repeat the recommendation of what started this DD tweet conversation: Schooled: The Price of College Sports (2013), which, as I've now seen it, is a really devastating attack on the NCAA and big-time football and men's basketball generally (what a surprise!). It's really, really well done, and is free on Amazon Prime and rentable on YouTube movies for (I think) around $8. One highly articulate ex-f00tballer makes the compelling case that the modern "student-athlete", at least in these sports, fits well the definition of what used to be an indentured servant.
Things that I keep thinking about watching this and other similar programs:
1. Professional internship programs
2. Minor league baseball
3. European apprentice style programs
They lost me when they talked about what the kids were getting being college tuition room and board. Because all those hopeful pros, are also getting access to world class coaching, facilities, and trainers. Why does Saban get to pick and choose his recruits, or Calipari, or Geno for that matter - because the recruits know those coaches are the best at getting their players trained up for a professional career.
If you want to complain about the amateur status of college football and basketball, look at the NFL and NBA. MLB would love to do away with the farm systems because it is a drain on their profits, but the NBA and NFL have never had to set up that kind of system because colleges provided it. And they provide the most important ingredient as well - the captive audience of millions of alumni willing to spend on 'their team' which is why the college games are so popular while other attempts at semi-pro leagues (and minor league baseball) have always lost money.
Oh yeah, indentured servitude - nope. College athletes are free to walk away at any moment they want and take their training and skills with them.