Nebrich was awful. He had the entire second quarter and showed nothing.
I don't get it.
He is inaccurate. Shows no poise. And has zero escapability.
Plus, when two plaers are equal, you give the job to the younger player.
What is going on?
He had one decent run and nothing else to show.....you can look for him all you want to be what you want him to be....but he's not. Watch the second quarter again.You are the one that's awful. MN had a limited amount of snaps in Q2 with McCumings having the balance.
overall i thought McEntee looked better throwing the ball than Nebrich. our inept second quarter sapped our defense and gave ISU a lof of momentum going into the second half. there were definitely a few passes where McEntee's footwork was terrible and his passes were all over the place as a result, but i think he looked more poised overall. McCummings was unquestionably the most productive, but he generally came in when we had the defense on their heels so i don't think we can just take everything at face value. i'm starting to lean towards McEntee taking 70% of the snaps with McCummings coming in situationally. let Nebrich take his redshirt year next year if he doesn't leap ahead of him in the offseason.
overall i actually like what i've seen of Nebrich, but he looks like he could use some time to bulk up and learn the offense better before taking the reins. his instincts seem good and he's athletic and shifty, but he just looks a little lost right now. once the speed of the game slows down for him i think he'll be a great player, but he's not there yet.
He looks good to me only when he throws straight downfield, but on wideouts and in the flat he sucks, in those situations his accuracy falls off a cliff.Mac played really well from the midpoint of the third quarter on. Before that, I would have stuck with McCummings. Nebrich looks third best to me. I don't blame the kid, he's a true frosh. But he locks on his man and can't move around the pocket very well, so he tends to panic.
Something was really really wrong with McEntee's mechanics for him to be spraying the ball like that. Then you saw him get some rhythm and he looked pretty good.
One of the things McEntee doesn't do well is hit a rb/wr moving away from him along the line of scrimmage. Not sure if it was just this game....but I think he under-threw/threw behind the receiver on 3 or 4 of these. I agree that his best throws are when he can step into the throw...he's just not as good in other situations and is completely immobile in the pocket.Mac played really well from the midpoint of the third quarter on. Before that, I would have stuck with McCummings. Nebrich looks third best to me. I don't blame the kid, he's a true frosh. But he locks on his man and can't move around the pocket very well, so he tends to panic.
Something was really really wrong with McEntee's mechanics for him to be spraying the ball like that. Then you saw him get some rhythm and he looked pretty good.
Mac played really well from the midpoint of the third quarter on. Before that, I would have stuck with McCummings. Nebrich looks third best to me. I don't blame the kid, he's a true frosh. But he locks on his man and can't move around the pocket very well, so he tends to panic.
Something was really really wrong with McEntee's mechanics for him to be spraying the ball like that. Then you saw him get some rhythm and he looked pretty good.
McEntee is Ivy League material.
Looked pretty good? The kid is a disaster. He has no presence, no mechanics, no ability to make plays, and he locks onto one receiver constantly. Every DB on the field knows exactly where and when the ball is going to receiver X. If he continues to get the number of snaps he's getting, we'll be lucky to eke out maybe 2 or 3 wins for the entire season.
At least McCummings made some plays while he was in there. He's no passer (missed the wide open one for a TD early in the game) but you've got to put the QB on the field who gives you the best chance to win. Pasqualoni was visibly upset with McEntee on numerous occasions throughout the game, yet he continued to trot him out there at crunch time.
McEntee is ok when no one is around him and he has time to throw. He gets spookedwhen he hears footsteps. McCummings is the best athlete and has a strong arm -but doesn"t read defenses well. Nebrich isn't ready yet. Decision time is coming up- play either McCummings or Nebrich and let them learn and hope you can win or keep going down with the Mac attack and hope he gives you the best chance of winning now. I would go wqith McCummings and dummy down the offense.
I don't know I saw some progress. Not a lot, but some anyway. I saw him not get as panicky and have a little more time and made some progress with accuracy. Don't flame, I said some.