Just finished Wyatt Earp and the Cowboy War (Netflix). Really disappointing because of how inaccurate it is. The true story of this war is mostly pieced together through interpretation of various sensationalist local newspaper stories of the time and some interviews with participants that had a strong incentive to shade the truth. There are a lot of pieces of the true story that are unknown. But of all the articles I have read about that war, in none of them is Ike Clanton the puppet master like he is portrayed in this documentary. In real life, he was at best a senior foot soldier in the gang, with Curly Bill Brocious and Johnny Ringo definitely more leaders of the gang, much as they were portrayed in the movie "Tombstone". There were other leaders of the gang, but Ike Clanton was not among them. He is most famous because he fled, abandoning his brothers to be killed at the shootout at the OK Corral.
Johnny Ringo, who was likely the leader of the cowboy gang and a total psychopath in real life, is not even mentioned in this documentary. The documentary focuses so much on Wyatt Earp, and makes him this two dimensional killer, where most reports of him from the time describe him as charismatic, and the complex relationship between Earp and Doc Holliday is kind of glossed over. The documentary also inexplicably anglicizes Holliday's Hungarian girlfriend, who was also portrayed more accurately in Tombstone.
Despite what the documentary claims, the war continued after the threat of Federal intervention, and both the Earp/Holliday gang and the Ringo/Brocious gang had been deputized by various authorities. The war really ended with Brocious' and then Ringo's death. I had hoped the documentary would dig into Ringo's death, which is a mystery to this day. It was ruled a suicide at the time, but that was a politically convenient assessment given that the Earp side had won the war with Ringo's death, and was trying to escape without consequences from a body count that had gotten huge. The movie Tombstone posits that Holliday killed Ringo. It could have been Holliday, or Earp, or someone else from their gang, but I think there is no way Ringo killed himself. Prior to his death, his side was at worst even, and possibly even winning the war. I think it is unlikely that a soulless killer like Ringo just gave up in that situation. Yet the documentary kept elevating Clanton rather than discuss one of the most interesting aspects of the war.
I find that fictional portrayals in film and TV are often more accurate than Netflix docu-dramas, and this is another example of that. The movie Tombstone is both more entertaining and more historically accurate, and I recommend watching it again rather than this documentary.