Week 4 NCAA Football | Page 3 | The Boneyard

Week 4 NCAA Football

Status
Not open for further replies.

nelsonmuntz

Point Center
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
44,521
Reaction Score
34,181
I know. When I heard Ohio State spent $20M NIL on the current team, it is other clear the sport is on borrowed time. There is not even a salary cap on college football, which will only make the rich spending even more each year. It is not possible for 99% of college football to keep up.

Upsets and being alums of colleges are what make college football fun even though it is not as crazy as March madness. When you take that away, you take the fun away. At that point, people will just watch pro sports.

The greed will kill the sport. There is no way media will keep paying for something that's just NFL lite when we already have the NFL.

NFL has a salary cap and revenue sharing.

College football is going to have 70-14 games regularly in conference play in a few years. No one will be interested in that product.
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2013
Messages
1,218
Reaction Score
2,325
NFL has a salary cap and revenue sharing.

College football is going to have 70-14 games regularly in conference play in a few years. No one will be interested in that product.
Counterpoint is that it is hard to assess high-school talent so we will always see variability
 
Joined
Sep 18, 2011
Messages
5,264
Reaction Score
21,029
NFL has a salary cap and revenue sharing.

College football is going to have 70-14 games regularly in conference play in a few years. No one will be interested in that product.
I was listening on Sirius to a few ex college football coaches talk and they all thought that you can't win consistently by heavily using the portal and using NIL to attract transfers. They thought that the core of your team has to be the development of HS players and then use the portal to fill a few holes.
 

nelsonmuntz

Point Center
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
44,521
Reaction Score
34,181
Counterpoint is that it is hard to assess high-school talent so we will always see variability

Who needs to assess high school talent with the transfer portal? Ohio State will have a payroll between direct payments and NIL, of over $40 million a year. How many schools even want to compete with that?
 

nelsonmuntz

Point Center
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
44,521
Reaction Score
34,181
I was listening on Sirius to a few ex college football coaches talk and they all thought that you can't win consistently by heavily using the portal and using NIL to attract transfers. They thought that the core of your team has to be the development of HS players and then use the portal to fill a few holes.

Edsall has a show on Sirius?
 
Joined
Sep 18, 2011
Messages
5,264
Reaction Score
21,029
Who needs to assess high school talent with the transfer portal? Ohio State will have a payroll between direct payments and NIL, of over $40 million a year. How many schools even want to compete with that?
Serious question. Is there really that much of a difference between Ohio St.'s roster in 2024 than the roster in 2014 before NIL? And, is there a difference in the coaching staff? OSU's coaching staff in 2014 had Urban Meyer, Tom Herman as OC, and Luke Fickell as DC. And, if you think money creates winning, how come the Yankees have only won 1 World Series in the past 20 years? You have to spend money smartly and develop your own players which is not easy to do.
 

nelsonmuntz

Point Center
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
44,521
Reaction Score
34,181
Serious question. Is there really that much of a difference between Ohio St.'s roster in 2024 than the roster in 2014 before NIL? And, is there a difference in the coaching staff? OSU's coaching staff in 2014 had Urban Meyer, Tom Herman as OC, and Luke Fickell as DC. And, if you think money creates winning, how come the Yankees have only won 1 World Series in the past 20 years? You have to spend money smartly and develop your own players which is not easy to do.

There is a $40 million/year of payroll difference. Do I really need to explain why that is a huge deal?
 
Joined
Nov 20, 2018
Messages
3,764
Reaction Score
12,804
Villanova hanging tougher vs Maryland than the Huskies did :(
oh damn. You reminded me to look up the score of that game after I looked at Maryland's schedule yesterday. Although Nova lost 38-20, I do think that is a little window dressing even though it was better than UConn's result against Maryland. Nova was down 24-0 by the 2nd qtr and then down 38-13 in the 4th qtr until Nova scored a late TD which probably matters more to bettors.
 
Joined
Nov 20, 2018
Messages
3,764
Reaction Score
12,804
3 yrs ago I'm sure he would have. After a couple years killing it at JMU, he’ll be on to a P4 (or P2 job like Cignetti)
That's why when I looked at the live score of the JMU-North Carolina game I got an uneasy feeling like missing out on a stock I could have purchased at a low price. Although I don't get into too many debates on the BoneYard, I did push back on people that stated UConn's lack of money is why football is so bad, which I think is BS. They should never have been historically bad like they have been for some of the years between 2012-2023 (i.e. 2017, 2018, etc.) Sure, UConn does not have a conference that the G5 schools do, but they have more money and brand recognition. There are schools doing far more with much less money and definitely less brand recognition.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Mar 4, 2014
Messages
17,475
Reaction Score
22,649
Serious question. Is there really that much of a difference between Ohio St.'s roster in 2024 than the roster in 2014 before NIL? And, is there a difference in the coaching staff? OSU's coaching staff in 2014 had Urban Meyer, Tom Herman as OC, and Luke Fickell as DC. And, if you think money creates winning, how come the Yankees have only won 1 World Series in the past 20 years? You have to spend money smartly and develop your own players which is not easy to do.
Money won't guarantee championships but it definitely helps put you in the playoffs. But yes, Ohio State and a few others who have dominated will continue to dominate.

It would be great if Central could upgrade to something like the MAC
Change the name to Central Connecticut University and it fits right in. With University of Connecticut to the Big Ten, of course.
 
Joined
Sep 18, 2011
Messages
5,264
Reaction Score
21,029
There is a $40 million/year of payroll difference. Do I really need to explain why that is a huge deal?
I understand the payroll difference, but the talent between the 2 rosters is similar. And, they had the #3 recruiting class in 2014 and the #5 recruiting class in 2024. The money is only keeping them in their position in college football.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
2,931
Reaction Score
10,025
And he makes only $550k — about what our coordinators make. Their staff makes far less. So it’s not all about money.
Been saying something along this line forever. I always thought we should just hire the entire staff of South Dakota State University. I still that would have worked.
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2013
Messages
1,218
Reaction Score
2,325
Been saying something along this line forever. I always thought we should just hire the entire staff of South Dakota State University. I still that would have worked.
And yet we all know that's not how it works
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Online statistics

Members online
251
Guests online
1,969
Total visitors
2,220

Forum statistics

Threads
158,715
Messages
4,165,555
Members
10,039
Latest member
jfreeds


.
Top Bottom