Tenspro2002 said:
The difference is that the "reaches" you describe in 2002 accounted for maybe 10-20 minutes per game, total. This year, that same caliber of player is receiving 10-20 minutes per game each. (The 2009 comparison isn't quite as apt -- Edwards is better than Facey and Austrie is better than TSam/Cassell.)
Edwards was benched on his high school team and his coach said there was no way he was playing at UConn. Obviously a personality conflict, since he was a pretty decent player. But he was never supposed to be a starter or significant factor based on his profile coming in - we hadn't even heard of him when be committed. Facey was a top 100 four star guy who was a NY POY and was expected to be a guy who would either start or at least contribute as an energy guy off the bench. Austrie was a little bit of a reach (probably going to UMass) based on AJ's health concerns, but a good pickup - he got the most out of his ability.
As I alluded to, the reason our reaches are playing 10-20 minutes each is that we aren't getting the high level of play from our top six to soak up most of the available 200 minutes. The 2002 team was really six deep with quality (with Hayes as a stopgap big when we had foul trouble). We have Boat, Purvis, Omar, DHam, Facey and Brimah (who was the one of the six who exceeded recruiting expectations) that on paper could be good enough to be a very good team, even leaving Cassell out of the picture (who was a disappointment - he seemed to have the potential to be a solid seventh guy). But only if all six played at a level that they were supposed to be. Boat, Hamilton and Brimah to a large degree, I think are fine. Purvis is sort of a Tony Robertson (scores a little, but can't play point) when I think there was hope (perhaps misguided) that he'd be closer to an all-conference level player. We won a lot of games with Tony, but with TB and BG, he never had to play point and with CB dominant, he could get us his 10-12 a night as a supplemental weapon. Omar's injuries/confidence slide have downgraded him from a probable key wing scorer into a role player, and Facey's potential as something maybe in between a Boone '04 and below KFree '99 type role player hasn't materialized since there isn't enough talent around him to give him chances to attack the glass. Probably safe to say he and Brimah (both of whom are raw) aren't a great pairing at this stage of their careers. Maybe next year when they have a little more polish.
Samuel and Cassell are asked to do more because we aren't getting much from Omar, and Purvis can't run the offense when we want to move Boat off the ball, and Facey isn't commanding minutes at the 4, forcing us to play DH there a lot and opening up more minutes 1-3. We won in '04 with only four perimeter guys at 3 spots (TB, BG, RA, DB), but Emeka, Boone and CV had all the minutes at the 4-5. In a perfect world, TSam could maybe be a part time defensive stopper when a guard was giving us trouble, or an energy guy like in the tourney last year, and Cassell maybe just in a zone buster role against certain teams when we were searching for a hot hand. But they wouldn't be guys we counted on for heavy minutes.