I think people are delusional if they think a P5 will ever pick us because of our football program. Our hopes reside in basketball and if that locks us out so be it. Our football program is now in permanent purgatory. We want to stay in a football conference to move up but unfortunately this football conference will never be good enough for us to do so as our recruiting is getting worst and worst. Let's just stop pretending we will ever be a good football program(our chances passed with the old big east) and join the new big east and save our Bball teams.
Nah, a P5 conference will pick us because:
1) We are one of the larger markets available
2) We'd give them a presence in NYC, at least for hoops
3) We provide suscribers for a confernence television network
4) We provide quality content over a broad range of sports for a confernence television network
5) We are an excellent academic institution
6) We are the best basketball school in the country (men)
7) We have a proven ability to win championships accross a broad range of sport (goes to quality of the athletics dept.)
8) We have excellent facilities (goes to quality of the athletics dept.)
9) We have nationwide name recognition.
10) We give them the ability so schedule games in NY/NE for their wealthy alumns to attend.
You are correct that they won't pick us because of football, currently, but existence of football is the key that unlocks door.
No football = no consideration.