To me its not about "juice", its about the history. If you don't think UConn-Pitt has a history, you drank way too much during the 2000's. There was a reason that the Kemba shot was such a big moment to me, Pitt always seemed tough and gritty, and we have a history of great showdowns in the rivalry.
I for one am very pleased, I'll be happy anytime we set up games against Pitt/Cuse/Gtown/Nova and even the teams that are not in our league at all like St Johns/Seton Hall/Notre Dame
Those were great showdowns because we were in the same conference. There's not going to be anything epic about playing a typical Pitt rugby match in November with nothing more at stake than bragging rights.
While I understand the desire to connect with the past in scheduling, I don't think it's in the program's interest to focus on that. Our scheduling focus needs to be national, not regional or historical.