All good points and much more informed than my original postSure, if all things were equal, but I don't think they were.
Carter's NIL Income is undisclosed, but that doesn't mean it was nothing. I love UConn, but doubt very much that UConn drew more eyeballs than MSU football, simply by virtue of who they play, week in & week out.
Carter wasn't just a JAG either. He was MSU's feature back in 2023 with >900 all-purpose yards against Big Ten competition. No other player was close. He was a captain in 2024 and led the Spartans with 5 Rushing TDs.
At the end of the day, he bet on himself and won. Multiple times over.

But to me, the best you get is undrafted? Really?
Look what Donald Brown did with us - staying the course in blue.
I still think NIL being the wildcard that there is a great case for players staying - UConn is televised each week, we get quite a bit of media coverage and it is perfectly good spot to have NFL scouts get a good look at you!