Geno can't win here.
During the summer I argued quite bit with the comment that Edwards is being wasted playing Power Forward. I disagreed big time with that. The counter they make is that in their opinion, Edwards won't be prepared for pro ball if she is stuck in the paint. I countered that Geno doesn’t pigeon-hole his players to one position/ one spot so even though she is a Power Forward, he'll let her shoot from the outside.
Now you are posting "She shouldn't be taking outside shots." If she were to stop doing that, then we'll hear comets ad nauseum that Geno doesn't "develop" his players.
Can’t win.
-------------------------
On a different subject- just asking your opinion and/or anyone else's; Can we officially stop ever ever speaking of assuming most players of a "sophomore jump" (not to say some players we can't suggest they will improve. I think CD in each of her next 3 years is gonna get pretty damn awesome.) again? I always felt that there used to be for the most part a soph jump.. Heck, last year Edwards looked so much better in the paint, didn't she? What has happened so far?
As to the first point, AE is not being developed throwing up shots from the foul line and beyond that she only rarely makes. She has natural size, strength, and athleticism but she is still not a developed inside player. She still has an awful lot of work to do in that regard. That's where her development should be right now.
Is the reason she is on the team to play in the pros? To be developed for the pros to the exclusion of the team winning? Is this just a tertiary level AAU experience? The questions are obviously rhetorical but I think the answers are clear. AE is never going to be a guard or wing in the WNBA as far as I can tell. I would not encourage her to take outside shots at this stage of her career until she can do the necessary things under the basket, on the blocks, or with a drive move, just like I would not encourage Nika to post up on offense. By the way, if AE just let's them fire at will it will hurt the team, as it did today.
Ok. The sophomore unjump. It's Nika also. I agree about AE, she was much better last year. I know BYers have suggested that just being on the Canadian National Team and practicing as opposed to playing in a competitive league or just working out with a trainer hurt her. I don't know what Nika did but the things she really needed to improve on, her 3, a drive move and pull up, and a drive move that finishes from both sides, do not seem to have happened at all although you could ague that her 3 is slightly improved. I wouldn't. I, like you, fully expected a jump but remember we really didn't get one from Aubrey last year either. Last year, not starting seemed to be comfortable for AE, this year starting is uncomfortable. Last year, starting seemed comfortable for Nika, but coming off the bench this year seems uncomfortable.
BTW, you want to see a sophomore jump. Despite her surgery, Paige was a better player this year before she got hurt than she was last year, and last year she was the best in the country. She worked her butt off and her strength enhancement showed as well as her skill enhancement. As for CD, she was looking at Geno after each mistake in the Seton Hall game to see if she was being yanked ( I was there and could see it). She has stopped looking. I think you are going to see a line on the graph going up each year with her. She moves better without the ball right now than anyone else on the team except Paige and misses really don't faze her anymore. That kid is a player.