I remember the Butler save/pass.
The Hawkin's dunk against G-town last year was up there, but I remember letting out an audible "Wow".
Spectacular can be bad as well. It might not be what you want to remember but the Marcus Williams steal and missed layup in the fina minute against Notre Dame had me not believe my eyes. He was having a big night too.
Runner-up for bad for me was I think Shamon Tooles inbounding the ball to Darius Rice for a Miami 3. I remember think Tooles had to keep the pass inside the 3-pt arc to prevent that exact thing from happening.
Bouknight putback stuff off his own missed shot was pretty special, too.