The Official 2025 New York Giants Thread

[husky8273]

Glad they played to win. Tanking is unconscionable.

 

[navery12]

Glad they played to win. Tanking is unconscionable.

Of course the team plays to win, but as a fan it's OK to admit winning significantly hurts the team going forward

 

[Scoe]

Well at least we got the qb and we’re not trying to draft the right qb. The win against the Colts a couple years ago was much worse, not sure what Giants could’ve done today really, the situation just sucks. I guess it’s good that Dart gets his first road win of course it would’ve been nice to have that accomplished in Denver months ago.

 

[Edward Sargent]

I love the AI articles speculating on whether Dart is the QB of the future.

 

[Hey Adrien!]

Just got back from visiting my wife’s family and just learned that my niece’s BF’s grandpa is Lionel Manuel. Go figure!

 

[Edward Sargent]

Well at least we got the qb and we’re not trying to draft the right qb. The win against the Colts a couple years ago was much worse, not sure what Giants could’ve done today really, the situation just sucks. I guess it’s good that Dart gets his first road win of course it would’ve been nice to have that accomplished in Denver months ago.

Do we have the qb? Wake up to article saying Schoen’s the man and that he might have used the #1 on Mendoza!!! Yep sounds like Schoen🤬 create a qb controversy in NY

 

[navery12]

Do we have the qb? Wake up to article saying Schoen’s the man and that he might have used the #1 on Mendoza!!! Yep sounds like Schoen🤬 create a qb controversy in NY

Yes, we have the QB. I want Schoen gone as much as anyone but that's just good business saying that about Mendoza. The #1 pick loses a ton of value as a trade chip if you come out and say you're not taking a QB

 

[FfldCntyFan]

I have a very strong suspicion that we're beating the Cowboys on Sunday and will end up picking behind Washington (who played Miami while we played New England, which could give them the strength of schedule benefit, even though they did beat us twice).

 

[navery12]

I have a very strong suspicion that we're beating the Cowboys on Sunday and will end up picking behind Washington (who played Miami while we played New England, which could give them the strength of schedule benefit, even though they did beat us twice).

If we win Sunday there's a good chance they're picking 7th

 

[Palatine]

 

[navery12]

Giants continue to be the only team in the NFL that doesn't understand the value of tanking

 

[CardiacAndre7]

I hate it here.

 

[Scoe]

Giants continue to be the only team in the NFL that doesn't understand the value of tanking

I guess we can get mad at Jackson Dart for being good

 

[navery12]

I guess we can get mad at Jackson Dart for being good

Not mad at Dart for being good, mad at the coaches that he was even in that game to look good

 

[Edward Sargent]

I’m hopeful. I like the O side of the Giants next year. The D side however needs a run stopper and a corner or two. Oh and we need a coach. I would be more hopeful if Schoen wasn’t doing the picking.

 

[FfldCntyFan]

While I am infinitely confident that the result of the Chiefs-Raiders game would have been different if we had lost today, to further my anger at how we finished the season, the way things shook out, we would have had the first pick in the draft if we did lose today.

If we win Sunday there's a good chance they're picking 7th

 

[gsmooth]

Just got back from visiting my wife’s family and just learned that my niece’s BF’s grandpa is Lionel Manuel. Go figure!

Damn I remember watching him with Phil Simms when I was a kid.

 

[gsmooth]

While I am infinitely confident that the result of the Chiefs-Raiders game would have been different if we had lost today, to further my anger at how we finished the season, the way things shook out, we would have had the first pick in the draft if we did lose today.

Well be mad the Giants went from the #2 pick to the #5 pick just based on today's games. That means if Dante Moore changes his mind and enters the draft, the Giants winning means they missed on being able to get a king's ransom for trading the #2 pick to a QB needy team.

 

[navery12]

I know the drop from 1 to 5 doesn't seem like the end of the world when you don't need a QB, but this is why the Giants desperately needed that trade down. They have a long wait after their round 2 pick

 

[Edward Sargent]

I know the drop from 1 to 5 doesn't seem like the end of the world when you don't need a QB, but this is why the Giants desperately needed that trade down. They have a long wait after their round 2 pick

View attachment 115590

oof.

 

[navery12]

What we all knew was coming is now official

 

[navery12]

I've been down on the Giants, but with a good hire at head coach and some smart FA moves this roster is definitely playoff caliber. Why I believe either of those will happen is beyond me though

 

[Edward Sargent]

I've been down on the Giants, but with a good hire at head coach and some smart FA moves this roster is definitely playoff caliber. Why I believe either of those will happen is beyond me though

No Thibs in this list and Cutting Okereke? No wanDale? Can’t count on Skatt after that injury. Elumenor should be RT. I also think Deonte Banks stays. Neal, Hyatt, Gano, Hudson are gone

 

[Edward Sargent]

Also Russell Wilsom

 

[navery12]

No Thibs in this list and Cutting Okereke? No wanDale? Can’t count on Skatt after that injury. Elumenor should be RT. I also think Deonte Banks stays. Neal, Hyatt, Gano, Hudson are gone

Yeah Thibodeaux should be on the list and I'd keep Okereke too. Wandale and Eluemunor are both free agents so still TBD if they stay, though I hope they bring both back. Both are getting $20M+ so my hopes are low though