JordyG
Stake in my pocket, Vlad to see you
- Joined
- Jan 21, 2016
- Messages
- 13,102
- Reaction Score
- 54,857
Somebody had to say it
While trying to listen to this I kept pushing the translate button and nothing happened. I had to quit 20 seconds in.
Somebody had to say it
There is room for all of it. Beauty is in the eye, or in this case, ear of the beholder. As Tony Williams sang , and before him Bill Kenny sang,"To Each His Own".I'll still take Billie's.
I'll still take Billie's.
I really liked the first B,S, and T released in 1968. Al Kooper led a very eclectic ensemble on Child Is Father to The Man, but he left and Katz and Colomby held the gang together, picked up David Clayton Thomas to do lead vocals, and went on to record some wonderful stuff. I was a freshman in college in 1969 when B, S, and T was released, and "And When I Die" was one of the brightest of many hits they produced. I especially appreciated Eric Satie's Variations on a Theme. You Made Me So Very Happy certainly did just that for many fans. So Billie is impeccable, but B,S and T paid homage very well. as for Summertime, Billie Ella, Louie, Janis were all great, but I love Billy Preston's unique take on that wonderful Gershwin tune. As for you being 8 years old when B,S and T was released, earth years and Lectron years must not align!I heard BST's first, so have a slight preference for it. (I think the album came out when I was about 8, and when my older sister went to college, I bought my own copy and have owned it ever since.) I do think it's cool that my father, having listened to Lady Day's version for 30 years, still liked BST's (not as much, but he still liked it). He also loved Janis Joplin's version of Summertime. Both of those modern renditions are either really creative or take many liberties with the songs, depending on your point of view.
Well if we're gonna do Sound of Silence, better do this version.I think most of Simon & Garfunkel's songs fit here. Several already, here's another.
Agreed. Of course just to put this into a more personal perspective, I saw both iterations of BS and T. Once with Al Kooper and twice with Clayton-Thomas. With Thomas it was just after his two albums with BS and T were released. I also saw Kooper with Mike Bloomfield doing that Super Session stuff. Although I liked Clayton-Thomas' versions for me personally they didn't come close.There is room for all of it. Beauty is in the eye, or in this case, ear of the beholder. As Tony Williams sang , and before him Bill Kenny sang,"To Each His Own".