Brown is a combo-guard (and a good one). We had Jalen and needed another PG, not combo. Also Brown was branded as an average or below-average shooter, more of a slashing CG. Alterique is the direct competition to Brown, not Vital. Vital wasn't brought in to be a PG, but was rather a branded shooter and lockdown defender. He filled a need, Brown did not.
To his credit, Brown shot 35% from 3 this year, much better than expected (Vital shot 37% on higher volume). He's played the 2-guard nicely at Miami.
Gilbert was the need and better fit, and it's a shame he got injured (along with like half the roster). Don't let a slew of injuries and a good freshman campaign from a former target lead you to "Ollie can't recruit/identify talent"
As for Colson, I'm not privy to how that recruitment went down, and hindsight 20/20 he would've been awesome here (same with Abu). That said, we ended up with Lubin that class, so I'm guessing there was some reason we didn't get him besides staff negligence. Projected forward though, Diarra, Polley, and Carlton are all recruits that fit the kind of 75-150 underrated stock riser bill. So when everyone complains we get these guys but not the Bonzie Colsons, they're talking out of both sides of their mouth.
Anyway, I'm willing to admit Brown is a nice player, but the staff went in a different direction. Roster management is part of recruiting, not just we should've gotten the guys who ended up being better than expectations.
Thanks for the thoughtful reply Mooch