Remind me why Mac starts? | The Boneyard

Remind me why Mac starts?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Palatine

Palatine

Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
28,435
Reaction Score
75,745
It can't be because Nebrich can't duplicate Mac performance.
 
MAc absolutely should be starting after last week. And he should absolutely be benched for the 2nd half due to his embarrassing play in the first half. I don't care who replaces him.
 
to coin a quote from a for coach "because he gives us the best chance to win"
 
After the Cuse game you would bench JMac ?? and bench him again after the Rutgers game ??? you can not be that clueless can you ?
 
it would not surprise me if Mac gets the starting nod next year, coach P seems to like the guy.
 
bigeastconf said:
it would not surprise me if Mac gets the starting nod next year, coach P seems to like the guy.
Expand ...
What benefit is it to Coach P to play favorites, instead of who he truly thinks gives us the best chance to win? Couldn't be more illogical... why is it so hard for folks to realize we just have a bunch of sub-par QB's on the roster? Hopefully that improves next season.
 
Mac wears #18. Those numbers in the teens mean that you are a QB. So if he wore #75 he would not be the QB. I took a logic course once.
 
HuskyBandDad said:
After the Cuse game you would bench JMac ?? and bench him again after the Rutgers game ??? you can not be that clueless can you ?[/quote

Yes, I'm not sure who the clueless one is here?? Oh wait yes I am................
Expand ...
 
Hmmmm, remind you why.....okay.

1. If we played McCummings, we'd get 9 in the box for the entire game.
2. Nebrich had his shot in practice and in games. He may have more talent and athletic ability, but he's a true freshman and is not ready yet.

There are legitimate gripes about this coaching staff. What they did at the quarterback position this season was their best bandaid on an open wound. They did not open the cut. By the end of the season, they had explored all of their options and made the most of the situation.
 
huskypantz said:
2. Nebrich had his shot in practice and in games. He may have more talent and athletic ability, but he's a true freshman and is not ready yet.
Expand ...

They blew the redshirt. At that precise moment, not being ready/being a freshman meant absolutely NOTHING. He should have played more and never got anything approaching a fair view. There is no way anyone can say with a straight face that Nebrich got a fair shot. He threw 14 passes. FOURTEEN.

To say he got a fair shot would be to trust the QB judgement of this coaching staff. I would love to know what on Earth anyone has seen to led them to give that trust.
 
zls44 said:
To say he got a fair shot would be to trust the QB judgement of this coaching staff. I would love to know what on Earth anyone has seen to led them to give that trust.
Expand ...

Yadda, yadda, yadda... Like Kornheiser likes to say, "Everybody's favorite player is the back-up quarterback."
 
huskypantz said:
Hmmmm, remind you why.....okay.

1. If we played McCummings, we'd get 9 in the box for the entire game.
2. Nebrich had his shot in practice and in games. He may have more talent and athletic ability, but he's a true freshman and is not ready yet.

There are legitimate gripes about this coaching staff. What they did at the quarterback position this season was their best bandaid on an open wound. They did not open the cut. By the end of the season, they had explored all of their options and made the most of the situation.
Expand ...

but what if you're moving the ball with "9 in the box"?

does that count for anything? moving the ball that is
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Online statistics

Members online
257
Guests online
1,985
Total visitors
2,242
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Share This Page

Forum statistics

Threads
164,085
Messages
4,381,612
Members
10,181
Latest member
tayjay15


.
..
Top Bottom