Kinda makes me wonder how the offer process works. With some kids like Ashlynn, KK, Ice, Ayanna they committed early in the process. But others seem to be caught up in contingency thinking. It sounds a bit like playing mah jongg.
Just my $.02 of course - take it with a grain of salt FWIW...
In the past, going back to all classes leading up to about the Ann Strother class, Geno would not recruit players early, in fact not until midway thru their junior years of high school. That was the rule.
That worked fine up until Ann Strother's class. She verbaled very late and ultimately chose UCONN, but there were some pretty famous reports of how badly Tennessee wanted her and how they had a mini blimp deliver her offer letter in TBA and also made tshirits with her baby picture on it. Fans were on pins and needles for her decision.
At any rate, immediately after that class, Geno completely struck out on all his top targets for 2003 and ended up with Sherwood, Wright and Robinson. Wright never even made it to campus and Sherwood and Robinson didn't make it to season 2. He realized pretty quickly that he needed to start recruiting kids sooner.
So like all great coaches, he changed with the times. The following class was Houston, Thomas, and Swanier. Hunter should have come, but her parents pushed her towards Duke. She stayed there 1 year, and most reports said deep down, she always wanted UCONN. Oh, what could have been. 2 knee injuries pretty much ruined her career.
Anyway, the next class of Montgomery, Greene, and role players Williams/Kern was really the last class where the old M.O. of recruiting late came to pass. Greene, IIRC, was a big surprise to UCONN fans and again IIRC, Geno went after her late in the process.
Then started the golden age. Tina Charles came next followed by Maya Moore, followed by Hayes, Doty, and EDD (oh what could have been).
Anyway that's a super long winded way of saying that for the most part, the staff is aware of kids when they are young, probably as early as 8th grade. They have gotten "in" with kids during their freshmen years, and like Ice did, some verbal as sophomores. I know Geno would "prefer" not to take verbals so early, but the times have changed and he's had to change with them. Geno actually prefers kids to verbal fairly quickly after mutual interest and visiting UCONN. He generally feels that the kids who work out the best know right away that UCONN is right for them.
I think also some kids just "know". They want the recruiting done and out of the way as it can be a huge distraction. Others enjoy the process and want to go on lots of visits. Others really have a hard time deciding and need to wait and really let the decision settle in their souls.