[Poll] Tim Boyle is... | Page 2 | The Boneyard

[Poll] Tim Boyle is...

Tim Boyle is...

  • The next coming of Dan Orlovsky

    Votes: 19 10.2%

  • A clear improvement over Whitmer and should start

    Votes: 66 35.3%

  • Not an upgrade over Whitmer and should have redshirted

    Votes: 29 15.5%

  • The worst QB since Johnny Mac

    Votes: 11 5.9%

  • Need more information

    Votes: 62 33.2%
  • Total voters
    187
Status
Not open for further replies.
uconnric said:
I'll say he's the best pure passer I've seen here since Dan O, but is faster and is better at running with the football. May even have a quicker release than Dan. There are some observations that can be made from his first performance, sure looks like he is real good one. Would have been nice to see Shak Phillips out there on Saturday.
Expand ...
Totally agree with you. You can tell by the way the ball comes out of his hand he's something special. Quick release, tight spirals and a cannon. They haven't had anyone who can do that since Dan. It's going to be great watching him develop into an NFL caliber QB
 
LRock34 said:
Need more info. The drops definitely hurt his stat line and prevented us from getting a win. He looked good at times and looked horrible at times. That's to be expected for a freshman QB. All that said I think we win on Saturday had Whitmer been on the field. There were a ton of drops but Boyle also killed a number of drives with wild throws. He was high or long far to often. I'm not making any excuses or Fox because he was horrendous but on both deep passes he was WIDE open. Had the balls been thrown with some touch they would have hit him in stride.

Boyle needs time to grow and learn. I think he should have been redshirted but learning on the field will be good for him.....but bad for Wiest's prospects of landing this job.
Expand ...

It's still hard to see us winning with Whitmer in there instead bro... Does Whitmer escape the pocket and gain yardage with his legs the way Boyle did? I honestly couldn't see Whitmer scampering for yardage like that. Seen enough of him to know that. He's prone to throw INT's too. We've all seen enough of that.
 
I think Boyle can be the next coming of Dan Orlovsky and still not be the right guy to be starting right now.

LOL at the poster who said Boyle is better than Dan. What could you have possibly seen on Saturday that would lead you to that conclusion?
 
nelsonmuntz said:
LOL at the poster who said Boyle is better than Dan. What could you have possibly seen on Saturday that would lead you to that conclusion?
Expand ...

from a pure talent standpoint (not accomplishment) Boyle obviously runs a lot better than Dan and I think has a stronger arm but I'm not 100% sure on that.

This poll is a landslide, less than 8% think Boyle should be redshirting. 65% think playing him was the right thing to do and 27% are afraid to take a stand on a silly poll.
 
.-.
Carl Spackler said:
I didn't record the game - forgot to - ESPN3 for the first month got me screwed up. But I did get a chance to watch the recording at a friends house last night. Boyle, I think - got damn lucky he didn't get picked off for 6 points in the final 3 minutes of the game. DAMN lucky. He made a bad, bad decision to throw into coverage in the middle of the field. Other than that single throw, I don't think he made many mental errors. He followed that up by pressing the issue on another ball, that turned into a dropped tip drill for USF, and it was not on target. If lady luck is going to smile though, I'm not going to complain. We need it.

He has work to do on getting his throws accurate, but that comes with reps and coaching. If he's not accurate a year from now - then there is an issue to discuss.

Most importantly to me - as I just noted elsewhere. The kid looked in charge. No doubt about it - IN CHARGE. That's what you need from the QB - above all other qualities.
Expand ...


If the earlier TD passes weren't dropped, Boyle's not in a position to have to make those throws that almost got picked. He'd be handing the ball off protecting a lead instead of trying to make something happen. I was pleased with his performance.
 
I'd prefer him to Whitmer, but mainly because Whitmer is terrible. But the idea he could be a great, the next Matty Ice based on what the BCU fans suggested early on, I don't see it. he is in the bottom 20% of QBs. which is better than the bottom 10% like Whitmer.
 
Jimmy Serrano said:
If anyone votes for anything other than "Need more information" it's based on emotion.
Expand ...

Palatine said:
Perhaps for you. Others may be quicker studies. I thought he showed more poise than CW. He showed a better arm. And he also ran better (a surprise).

Agreed it's a small sample size. But it's enough to make a judgement.
Expand ...

Thanks to this bump, I'd like to take this time to remind everyone that Palatine never said Boyle would be better than Whitmer. He just said that he deserved a chance to play. His track record regarding backup QB's remains flawless.

Thank you.
 
.-.
Jimmy Serrano said:
Thanks to this bump, I'd like to take this time to remind everyone that Palatine never said Boyle would be better than Whitmer. He just said that he deserved a chance to play. His track record regarding backup QB's remains flawless. Thank you.
Expand ...

Maybe so. But he didn't need to such a dick about it or start a new thread about it every 3 days.
 
J187Money said:
Maybe so. But he didn't need to such a dick about it or start a new thread about it every 3 days.
Expand ...
It's a condition. The only explanation is he's like Chucky in Sons of Anarchy :eek:.
 
Bubba1957 said:
Totally agree with you. You can tell by the way the ball comes out of his hand he's something special. Quick release, tight spirals and a cannon. They haven't had anyone who can do that since Dan. It's going to be great watching him develop into an NFL caliber QB
Expand ...
Geez. Wonder if Jaws or Grunden would like my help? I must have a real talent for QB eval.
 
Uconnalliance said:
Where's the vote for transfer?
Expand ...


He us not leaving UCONN much to your displeasure.

Not sure who will start this year but he will have every chance to win the quarterback battle
 
uconnbill said:
He us not leaving UCONN much to your displeasure.

Not sure who will start this year but he will have every chance to win the quarterback battle
Expand ...
no displeasure, love the kid but their seems to be a log jam at qb
 
.-.
One thing's for sure. He's not keeping Tom Brady up at night worrying about his job.
 
J187Money said:
Maybe so. But he didn't need to such a dick about it or start a new thread about it every 3 days.
Expand ...

Actually Palatine spent many posts on many threads telling us he didn't say what I just quoted him as saying.

So not only was he a dick about it, he was lying as well. CTMike, myself, and others called him out over this and he maintained his position that he only said Boyle deserves a chance. After Boyle's performance he didn't offer up a mea culpa....he claimed he never said what he said.
 
Uconnalliance said:
no displeasure, love the kid but their seems to be a log jam at qb
Expand ...
LOL -

BY line of the year 'we have a log jam at the QB position'...we need 2 QB's before we have a log jam - as of today we have 0.
 
Tim Boyle is.... Somewhat tall with a strong throwing arm. That's all I got.
 
.-.
Jimmy Serrano said:
Actually Palatine spent many posts on many threads telling us he didn't say what I just quoted him as saying.

So not only was he a dick about it, he was lying as well. CTMike, myself, and others called him out over this and he maintained his position that he only said Boyle deserves a chance. After Boyle's performance he didn't offer up a mea culpa....he claimed he never said what he said.
Expand ...

He did predict Orlovsky would be better than Keron Henry. Can't take that away from him. Edsall didn't even know what he was sitting on.
 
i put Lorenzen as the worst QB in the last 15 years and Whitmer as #2. Right now Boyle is making a strong case to be in the top 3.
 
Haha, that's funny

Lorenzen was awful. No wonder Iowa St, not exactly a powerhouse, immediately converted him to TE, and then the NFL later tied too. That's an example of a stupid decision, let me be so thick headed that I'll do something that has no benefit to my long term financial future. Maybe 3-4 years as a TE and he's still in NFL, not just a practice squad player for 1.

huskysupporter said:
Lorenzen was the second best qb of the D 1 era behind Orlovsky.
Expand ...
 
.-.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,258
Messages
4,560,194
Members
10,448
Latest member
MillerLitEd


Top Bottom