I think this thread started out with great intentions, and a hopefulness that Phil - a 4 year guy who committed to our program and stayed when we were facing sanctions, has worked his tail off for the team, contributed very important minutes and plays during our NC run, and has visibly struggled for most of last year - will be able to come out on top his senior year and display his potential. I don't think anyone was trying to say that he was some kind of great player or going to be our next All American, but it's a reminder that even though he received a ton of crap for his play at times last year, he is still a husky that all of us should be proud to have on the team.
If you don't think he'll be a good player this season - that's your prerogative. But don't crap on the guy who's given his all and still is going to for the next year. I think everyone here is hopeful he's going to turn around his misfortune from last year and go out on top. Anyone watching the games at the end of the year noticed a difference and saw a lot more of Phil's potential.