OT: Rock music game | The Boneyard

OT: Rock music game

QDOG5

QDOG5

I dont have a drug problem I have a police problem
Joined
Jan 6, 2016
Messages
2,051
Reaction Score
9,554
Too much Covid for me so here is a silly game. There are no winners/losers. We might find out who we would attend a concert with after we all get vaccinated:)
Pick one of the two.

Jim Morrison vs. Van Morrison
Eddie Vedder vs. Eddie Van Halen
Jeff Beck vs. Beck
Bob Dylan vs. Bob Marley
Stevie Ray Vaughn vs. Stevie Nicks
Jimmy Page vs. Jimi Hendryx
Elvis Presley vs. Elvis Costello
Smokey Robinson vs. Chris Robinson
Deadheads vs. Parrotheads
Chicago vs. Kansas
Queen vs. Prince
Black Sabbath vs. Pink Floyd
 
1. Pass. Stay home and watch Survivor.
2. EVH
3. Jeff Beck though I like Beck's music more--I just don't want to be abducted by his Scientologist henchmen
4. Bob Marley, are you kidding me?
5. Stevie Nicks, come on. Every man or woman who answers this will say Nicks.
6. Hendrix. He's cool and chill. I don't want people who stuff fish into orifices.
7. Elvis Costello.
8. Smokey, I guess.
9. Pass. Stay home and watch Big Brother.
10. Pass. Stay home and watch The Real World.
11. Very very tough decision. I'd rather hang out with Queen but how can I pass up Let's Go Crazy? Prince.
12. Pink Floyd.
 
Van Morrison - one of my all time favs
Eddie Van Halen - could not go wrong
Beck - never exposed to Jeff
Bob Dylan - two legends Dylan has the volume
Stevie Nicks - need a lady at this party
Jimi Hendrix - original
Elvis Presley the King
Smokey Robinson - smooth
Parrotheads - would like to go to a dead show with parrrotheads
Chicago - gotta have some horns
Prince - funk it up a bit
Pink Floyd
 
Jim
Van
Jeff
Dylan
Vaughn
Hendrix
Costello
Smokey
Dead
Chicago
Queen
Floyd
 
The tough one - Van Morrison due to longevity and total package
Eddie Van Halen - substance over blather
Jeff Beck - one of the greatest guitarists who gets little love
Tie - both great at their own genre 2 great Bobs
Stevie Ray V - creativity matters
Hendrix - have to go with the original master of amplifier music - also a great blues man
The King - hands down
Chris Robinson - the last hippie
Deadheads - not even close
Chicago - a classic band - the first 2 albums are absolute must haves
Queen - only because I love their music more than Prince
Pink Floyd - Dark Side of the Moon stands alone
 
Jim Morrison
Eddie Vedder
Jeff Beck
Bob Dylan
Stevie Ray Vaughn
Jimmy Page
Elvis Costello
Smokey Robinson
Deadheads
Neither. Hate both.
Queen
Pink Floyd
 
.-.
I think all Chicago fans would have traded Peter Cetera to Kansas for a musician to be named later. Probably would have worked out better for both bands.

Van Morrison- Not a fan of either but Morrison is so overrated
Eddie Van Halen- When Spicoli won a wad of cash saving Brooke Shields he knew who to hire for his bday party. (Don't bore me with details like Vedder hadn't accomplished anything when Fast Times came out).
Jeff Beck- This is the only #1 vs play-in winner in the bracket.
Bob Marley- Bob wrote great songs and sange from the heart but Bob sang songs better and sang from his soul.
Stevie Ray Vaughn- Nicks annoys me for the damn social media meme suggesting she is such an alpha for writing the lyrics for Go Your Own Way and made Lyndsey sing them. Actually Lyndsey wrote them and made her sing them.
Jimmy Page- Hendryx is nothing more than a cover band for The Jimmy Hendrix Experience
Elvis Presley- The King
Smokey Robinson- Really thought Black Crowes had a chance to go on a 20 year run of excellence. Props to Chris for banging Goldie's daughter for a bit.
Parrotheads- They're annoying but they smell less and leave less waste behind
Chicago- See opening comment
Prince- His stuff still sounds fresh today
Pink Floyd- By the way, which one's Pink? @nomar , thanks for the education on that one. Also, check out our conversation a month before the election. You and I were way better prognosticating than any professional pollsters.
 
Really cool list/question, it's too difficult. Most will pick Smokey but I just have to give a shout-out to Chris Robinson. He sounds absolutely amazing these days, great to see him back with his bro.

 
Van Morrison
Eddie Van Halen
Jeff Beck
Bob Dylan
Stevie Ray Vaughn
Jimmy Page
Elvis Presley
Smokey Robinson
Deadheads
Kansas
Queen
Pink Floyd
 
I think I read this wrong. Most people are answering what concert they'd rather attend after covid. I answered who I'd rather have pick me up in a limo so we could attend, say, I dunno, a Miley Cyrus concert together.
 
Jim Morrison vs. Van Morrison - Teenage Deepster says Jim, Current Deepster says Van
Eddie Vedder vs. Eddie Van Halen - EVH 1000%
Jeff Beck vs. Beck - Jeff...although I don't really care for either
Bob Dylan vs. Bob Marley - Marley. Not close.
Stevie Ray Vaughn vs. Stevie Nicks - SRV.
Jimmy Page vs. Jimi Hendryx - Hendrix. Page without Plant is nothing.
Elvis Presley vs. Elvis Costello - The King. And I've been to Graceland.
Smokey Robinson vs. Chris Robinson - Chris. Not close.
Deadheads vs. Parrotheads - Deadheads. Jimmy Buffett music stinks.
Chicago vs. Kansas - Chicago.
Queen vs. Prince - Queen. They don't fit any specific genre, but cross over into like 8 of them.
Black Sabbath vs. Pink Floyd - Pink Floyd. If they ever decided to tour, there'd be no max ticket price.
 
.-.
Jim Morrison vs. Van Morrison
Eddie Vedder vs. Eddie Van Halen
Jeff Beck vs. Beck
Bob Dylan vs. Bob Marley
Stevie Ray Vaughn vs. Stevie Nicks
Jimmy Page vs. Jimi Hendryx
Elvis Presley vs. Elvis Costello
Smokey Robinson vs. Chris Robinson
Deadheads vs. Parrotheads
Chicago vs. Kansas
Queen vs. Prince
Black Sabbath vs. Pink Floyd
 
Van Morrison. Not close. Really don’t like Jim.
Eddie Van Halen, another easy one.
Jeff Beck maybe easiest of all.
Bob Dylan vs. Bob Marley. Finally a tough call, I’ll say Dylan.
Stevie Ray Vaughn vs. Stevie Nicks. How old is Stevie Nicks at this concert? Young Nicks wins but old Nicks loses to Stevie Ray
Jimmy Page in a close one
Elvis Presley absolutely
Smokey Robinson eAst
Parrotheads for sure. I am one.
Chicago vs. Kansas. Toss up, prefer old Chicago music, but I’ll go with Kansas.
Queen
Black Sabbath. I feel like you want to party with Ozzy.
 
Morrison
Vedder
Beck
Dylan
Hendrix***
Costello
Chris Robinson
Phish-Heads
Don't Care
Prince
Sabbath
 
First, typo on Hendrix. Second, I was thinking of what yarders have similar music tastes and therefore I'd be more likely to attend concerts with those people. Also, I'm not just considering the individuals but the bands they played in. My list is
Jim
Vedder
Beck
Marley
SRV
Page
Costello
Chris
Deadheads
Chicago
Queen
Floyd
 
Last edited:
QDOG5 said:
Too much Covid for me so here is a silly game. There are no winners/losers. We might find out who we would attend a concert with after we all get vaccinated:)
Pick one of the two.

Jim Morrison vs. Van Morrison
Eddie Vedder vs. Eddie Van Halen
Jeff Beck vs. Beck
Bob Dylan vs. Bob Marley
Stevie Ray Vaughn vs. Stevie Nicks
Jimmy Page vs. Jimi Hendryx
Elvis Presley vs. Elvis Costello
Smokey Robinson vs. Chris Robinson
Deadheads vs. Parrotheads
Chicago vs. Kansas
Queen vs. Prince
Black Sabbath vs. Pink Floyd
Expand ...

Doors
Vedder
Jeff
Dylan
Nicks
Page
Elvis
Smokey
No clue of either
Chicago
Queen
Floyd
 
QDOG5 said:
Too much Covid for me so here is a silly game. There are no winners/losers. We might find out who we would attend a concert with after we all get vaccinated:)
Pick one of the two.

Jim Morrison vs. Van Morrison
Eddie Vedder vs. Eddie Van Halen
Jeff Beck vs. Beck
Bob Dylan vs. Bob Marley
Stevie Ray Vaughn vs. Stevie Nicks
Jimmy Page vs. Jimi Hendryx
Elvis Presley vs. Elvis Costello
Smokey Robinson vs. Chris Robinson
Deadheads vs. Parrotheads
Chicago vs. Kansas
Queen vs. Prince
Black Sabbath vs. Pink Floyd
Expand ...
Both
Van Halen
Jeff Beck
Dylan
Nicks
Both
Presley
Smokey
Deadheads
Both
Queen
Both
 
.-.
Jim Morrison
Eddie Vedder
Beck
Bob Marley
Stevie Nicks
Jimmy Page
Elvis Presley
Chris Robinson
Parrotheads
Chicago
Queen
Black Sabbath
 
Van Morrison
Eddie Van Halen
Jeff Beck
Bob Dylan
Stevie Ray Vaughn
Jimmy Page vs. Jimi Hendryx
Elvis Costello
Pass
Parrotheads
Pass
Queen
Pink Floyd
 
QDOG5 said:
Too much Covid for me so here is a silly game. There are no winners/losers. We might find out who we would attend a concert with after we all get vaccinated:)
Pick one of the two.

Jim Morrison vs. Van Morrison
Eddie Vedder vs. Eddie Van Halen
Jeff Beck vs. Beck
Bob Dylan vs. Bob Marley
Stevie Ray Vaughn vs. Stevie Nicks
Jimmy Page vs. Jimi Hendryx
Elvis Presley vs. Elvis Costello
Smokey Robinson vs. Chris Robinson
Deadheads vs. Parrotheads
Chicago vs. Kansas
Queen vs. Prince
Black Sabbath vs. Pink Floyd
Expand ...
  • Jim Morrison. Sorry Van fans, don't like him.
  • Eddie Van Halen. I find Pearl Jam annoying even though my wife is obsessed with Vedder.
  • Beck. For me, one of the most inspirational musicians for me growing up. In the mid-90s his creativity was off the charts.
  • More of a toss up than like ten years ago, but I'll still go with Marley but I like Dylan in small doses.
  • Stevie Nicks. Growing up, my dad was a huge Fleetwood Mac fan and still love their music to this day.
  • Jimmy Page. Zeppelin are my favorite classic rock fan.
  • I guess Elvis. Not a fan of either.
  • Smokey Robinson lean.
  • Deadheads, easy.
  • I guess Kansas.
  • Prince, although I really like a lot of Queen's songs.
  • Pink Floyd. "Fearless" is one of my favorite songs of all-time. I listen to it every time I take off from the runway.
 
Jim Morrison
Eddie Vedder - if he plays his much earlier stuff, otherwise, will pick another early 90s group
Jeff Beck
Bob Marley (already seen Bob Dylan)
Stevie Ray Vaughn
Jimi Hendrix
Elvis Costello
No clue who either of those is
What? Deadheads, as in, Grateful Dead (tribute band)?
Chicago - if they play their earlier stuff from the late 60s
Queen
Pink Floyd
 
Jim Morrison vs. Van Morrison
Eddie Vedder vs. Eddie Van Halen
Jeff Beck vs. Beck
Bob Dylan vs. Bob Marley
Stevie Ray Vaughn vs. Stevie Nicks
Jimmy Page vs. Jimi Hendrix - Even fixed the spelling for you
Elvis Presley vs. Elvis Costello
Smokey Robinson vs. Chris Robinson
Deadheads vs. Parrotheads
Chicago vs. Kansas
Queen vs. Prince
Black Sabbath vs. Pink Floyd
 
Jim Morrison vs. Van Morrison - Never like the Doors, but Jim Morrison seems like he would be way more fun to see in concert.
Eddie Vedder vs. Eddie Van Halen - Vedder has a cool voice, but EVH is a legend
Jeff Beck vs. Beck - Don't know Jeff Beck's music
Bob Dylan vs. Bob Marley - Tough one, but how could one pass up Marley?
Stevie Ray Vaughn vs. Stevie Nicks
Jimmy Page vs. Jimi Hendryx - Mount Rushmore of guitarists. Not sure whom I would pick over Hendricks, if anyone.
Elvis Presley vs. Elvis Costello - Please
Smokey Robinson vs. Chris Robinson - Don't know Smokey
Deadheads vs. Parrotheads - Write-in vote for Juggalos
Chicago vs. Kansas - I know one song between these two bands, unless "Dust in the Wind" is by Kansas. Then it's two.
Queen vs. Prince
Black Sabbath vs. Pink Floyd
 
.-.
Van Morrison
Eddie Van Halen
Jeff Beck
Bob Marley
Stevie Ray Vaughn
Jimmy Page
Elvis Costello
Smokey Robinson
Deadheads vs. Parrotheads hard pass on both
Chicago vs. Kansas hard pass on both
Prince
Pink Floyd
 
Rico444 said:
Jim Morrison vs. Van Morrison
Eddie Vedder vs. Eddie Van Halen
Jeff Beck vs. Beck
Bob Dylan vs. Bob Marley
Stevie Ray Vaughn vs. Stevie Nicks
Jimmy Page vs. Jimi Hendrix - Even fixed the spelling for you
Elvis Presley vs. Elvis Costello
Smokey Robinson vs. Chris Robinson
Deadheads vs. Parrotheads
Chicago vs. Kansas
Queen vs. Prince
Black Sabbath vs. Pink Floyd
Expand ...
Got them all except Queen... and that was iffy.
 
uconnfan68 said:
Got them all except Queen... and that was iffy.
Expand ...

I think Queen is so underrated. Freddie is obviously one of the best ever to do it, but Brian May is ridiculously talented. They made so many great songs; they're just such a fun band to rock out to. If I ever need to get pumped up for anything, I'll throw on "Don't Stop Me Now" and that never fails to jack me up.
 
Rico444 said:
I think Queen is so underrated. Freddie is obviously one of the best ever to do it, but Brian May is ridiculously talented. They made so many great songs; they're just such a fun band to rock out to. If I ever need to get pumped up for anything, I'll throw on "Don't Stop Me Now" and that never fails to jack me up.
Expand ...

The key to Don't Stop Me Now is to watch it in Shaun of the Dead.

 
QDOG5 said:
Too much Covid for me so here is a silly game. There are no winners/losers. We might find out who we would attend a concert with after we all get vaccinated:)
Pick one of the two.

Jim Morrison vs. Van Morrison
Eddie Vedder vs. Eddie Van Halen
Jeff Beck vs. Beck
Bob Dylan vs. Bob Marley
Stevie Ray Vaughn vs. Stevie Nicks
Jimmy Page vs. Jimi Hendryx
Elvis Presley vs. Elvis Costello
Smokey Robinson vs. Chris Robinson
Deadheads vs. Parrotheads
Chicago vs. Kansas
Queen vs. Prince
Black Sabbath vs. Pink Floyd
Expand ...

Jesus there is only one tough one on here.

1) van. Jim Morrison is a fraud buffoon.
2) Van Halen ( and I reall like and know personally ( for two days and 4 hours of shooting pool, Eddie vedder, great singer and great guy but Eddie Van Halen reinvented an instrument whether you love him or hate him)
3) Jeff beck not close
4) this one torture. Because Marley beats everyone else on list, but Dylan by a mile.
5) SRV
6) Hendrix. Page a great songwriter (at least on the stuff he didnt steal) but totally overrated guitar player.
7) has to be Presley,
8) Smokey,
9) deadheads. Parrot heads are a cheap drunken imitation but I’m one of those too
10) this is the Lol. Chicago, Kansas shouldn’t be in same breath or universe.
11) actually second toughest. But Queen
12) Floyd. I like good sabbath Floyd’s output rules that
 
Last edited:
.-.
You must log in or register to reply here.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,535
Messages
4,581,060
Members
10,491
Latest member
7774Forever


Top Bottom