A difference, yes. Likely that it would have changed the outcome, no.So, Mel Thomas getting hurt in 2008 made no difference on UConn's chances in 2008?
I'll give you a never injured Achonwa for a never injured Tuck/Banks/KML.You do know Achonwa was injured, and didn't play, right?
Aeffingmen!!!Watch the video again. Right from the opening tipoff, Uconn pushed the ball inside to take advantage of Achonwa's absence. That would nullify your point. But that wasn't my point anyway. MHS said that ND choked. Harsh.
Would you say that the 2001 UConn team, the one that Geno said was he greatest team, "choked", and ignore the fact that Sveta and Shea were injured, and freshman DT went 2 for 18? At least be consistent.
To be clear, I'm not saying ND would have won with Achonwa, but Achonwa was a team Captain and leader, and was playing the best basketball of her career when she went down in the game just before the final four. To say her absence didn't make any difference is probably one of the reasons that many people dislike UConn fans. Double standard.
Recognized for what, choking in the big game?
That's all I'm saying about Achonwa.A difference, yes. Likely that it would have changed the outcome, no.
Not really a valid comparison. ND lost Achonwa a week before the NC game. There was little time for coaches to adapt to her absence. Banks and KML were healthy for the NC game and Tuck was not a starter (and was injured early enough in the season to get a redshirt). I'm not going to blame the loss on Achonwa's absence, but that one poster claimed ND choked. There was no way that ND was a favorite in this game, especially after the Achonwa injury.I'll give you a never injured Achonwa for a never injured Tuck/Banks/KML.
Both teams at 100% full strength.
Injuries are an unfortunate part of the game, we all know that. I am not comfortable with those who state that Achonwa not playing had no effect as if it were fact. They certainly are entitled to their opinion, but the fact is we will never know what the outcome of the game would have been, and that diminishes the game somewhat. A large part of UConn's victory was their ability to attack to middle at will, with most of their points coming within ten feet of the basket. To say that would have happened with Achonwa playing, when it had never happened before against ND is a little short-sighted.I'll give you a never injured Achonwa for a never injured Tuck/Banks/KML.
Both teams at 100% full strength.
Not really a valid comparison. ND lost Achonwa a week before the NC game. There was little time for coaches to adapt to her absence. Banks and KML were healthy for the NC game and Tuck was not a starter (and was injured early enough in the season to get a redshirt). I'm not going to blame the loss on Achonwa's absence, but that one poster claimed ND choked. There was no way that ND was a favorite in this game, especially after the Achonwa injury.
The whole thread mocking the honoring of the ND WBB team is disappointing. The team was honored at halftime of a football game (not that big of a deal). They made the FF 4 years in a row. They were the first ND basketball team to make the NC game undefeated. These are all accomplishments that any team not named UConn would take pride in.
The whole thread mocking the honoring of the ND WBB team is disappointing. The team was honored at halftime of a football game (not that big of a deal). They made the FF 4 years in a row. They were the first ND basketball team to make the NC game undefeated. These are all accomplishments that any team not named UConn would take pride in.
It wasn't meant to be a direct comparison. It is merely a fact that neither team was at full strength in that game.Not really a valid comparison. ND lost Achonwa a week before the NC game. There was little time for coaches to adapt to her absence. Banks and KML were healthy for the NC game and Tuck was not a starter (and was injured early enough in the season to get a redshirt). I'm not going to blame the loss on Achonwa's absence, but that one poster claimed ND choked. There was no way that ND was a favorite in this game, especially after the Achonwa injury.
The whole thread mocking the honoring of the ND WBB team is disappointing. The team was honored at halftime of a football game (not that big of a deal). They made the FF 4 years in a row. They were the first ND basketball team to make the NC game undefeated. These are all accomplishments that any team not named UConn would take pride in.
-Man, I don’t know anything about Rembrandt....Rembrandt's Night Watch...notice the use of the bright colored clothing to distinguish the central figure...it has been suggested that Rembrandt meant to caste the gelded figure in the role of marionette...
Injuries, are without question, an unfortunate part of the game as any UCONN fan is keenly aware. Who knows how many more titles the Huskies would have if not for season and career ending injuries to multiple AAs.Injuries are an unfortunate part of the game, we all know that. I am not comfortable with those who state that Achonwa not playing had no effect as if it were fact. They certainly are entitled to their opinion, but the fact is we will never know what the outcome of the game would have been, and that diminishes the game somewhat. A large part of UConn's victory was their ability to attack to middle at will, with most of their points coming within ten feet of the basket. To say that would have happened with Achonwa playing, when it had never happened before against ND is a little short-sighted.
Here are what I consider facts:
Notre Dame won seven of the previous nine meetings. But, UConn won two previous meetings in the Final four. Notre Dame in the regular season ran through their opponents, winning by an average of 25.6 points while taking both the conference regular season and tournament championships. Notre Dame played inspired basketball in the Final Four win over Maryland where Notre Dame outrebounded the Terps by a record margin.
Those are facts. How Notre Dame would have done with Achonwa is total speculation.
Fortunately, Geno was far more gracious than some UConn fans:
"We beat a great, great team," Auriemma said. "Notre Dame is a great team. For them to have the season they had and lose their starting center and to do what they did, I can't say enough about their players, coaching staff and it took everything we have. I knew if we played great we'd have a chance to win."
My uncle, no mean artist in his own right even though he made his living as an architect, informed me as a boy that Rembrandt was ridiculing the man in the bright clothing by casting him as a fop and a poseur...gelded was a little cruder description than I intended for the gentile BY audience...my apologies...-Man, I don’t know anything about Rembrandt.
-Actually I thought, back then, they only casted gelded guys into the role of soprano, unless of course… are you sayin...
-So, is Rembrandt suggesting the Night Watch is voting here on who must become a (gulp) permanent harem guard???
-Geez, no wonder everyone showed up at the meeting with a weapon!
To say her absence didn't make any difference is to say it would have changed the result, a comment with which virtually fans and commentators agree. It's not a knock against the kid, who had a great career, it is just comment on the difference between the two teams. ND had a great season for them. Not losing until the championship game is a great year for most programs, just not the one that this forum follows.Watch the video again. Right from the opening tipoff, Uconn pushed the ball inside to take advantage of Achonwa's absence. That would nullify your point. But that wasn't my point anyway. MHS said that ND choked. Harsh.
Would you say that the 2001 UConn team, the one that Geno said was he greatest team, "choked", and ignore the fact that Sveta and Shea were injured, and freshman DT went 2 for 18? At least be consistent.
To be clear, I'm not saying ND would have won with Achonwa, but Achonwa was a team Captain and leader, and was playing the best basketball of her career when she went down in the game just before the final four. To say her absence didn't make any difference is probably one of the reasons that many people dislike UConn fans. Double standard.
That's great. Recognized for reaching the FF. Quite an accomplishment.
My uncle, no mean artist in his own right even though he made his living as an architect, informed me as a boy that Rembrandt was ridiculing the man in the bright clothing by casting him as a fop and a poseur...gelded was a little cruder description than I intended for the gentile BY audience...my apologies...
Thank you for not saying "classless". That's what I was thinking, though. This thread is very much reminiscent of the Summitt in its heyday.The whole thread mocking the honoring of the ND WBB team is disappointing.
This thread belies your statement. Sadly, you also questioned FightinChoke's manners for defending his team.I believe we are much more fair-minded than your coach, who was unwilling to give even a minimal applause for Stewie at a public event when she was honored for her excellence.
No, I meant that you weren't Jewish...or spellcheck and remedial typing skills are a bad combo...ahem.
genteel.
I liked your post, FC, and you are one of the most well-mannered and knowledgeable people posting in WCBB, so it's always a pleasure reading your posts. That said, you seem to have forgotten some of your coach's behavior leading up to the NC last year. I'm a guest here, as you are, but I can tell you that if Muffet meant it to be irritating, she was extremely successful. Don't you think it's a bit much to ask any fans to just let all that slide without expressing some rancor. I honestly cannot, because it still rankles me.The whole thread mocking the honoring of the ND WBB team is disappointing. The team was honored at halftime of a football game (not that big of a deal). They made the FF 4 years in a row. They were the first ND basketball team to make the NC game undefeated. These are all accomplishments that any team not named UConn would take pride in.
This thread belies your statement. Sadly, you also questioned FightinChoke's manners for defending his team.