It’s an interesting question. There was a time when many French people did not want to speak English, and some pretended not to be able to speak English with the English and Americans. After all, these foreigners were in our country, and they should speak our language. There was a belief that French, the international language until maybe WWII, could complete against English. There was also a belief in French exceptionalism, that France has a special place in world history and in the current world.Interesting. Years ago I had the opportunity to spend an extended time in France. I noticed that often when I asked people if they spoke English in causal settings they would say no, but once I said OK and switched to French they often would drop in to English and speak that with me. Some people surmised that they wanted me to make the effort, but I think that a different mechanism was at work.
I think that it may have been as simple as the standard for what it means to “speak a foreign language” in Europe being far higher than in in the US. So when I asked people, in English, whether they spoke English, they may have been reticent to say that they did because it wasn’t flawless. Once they heard my very best efforts at French, they were no longer uncomfortable about their English which was inevitably significantly better than my French.
Does that ring true to you?
About 15 years ago I starting seeing a lot of newspaper articles here about the death of French and by extension France itself. This fear can be seen in the growing support for Le Pen’s nationalist party rooted in fascism. I now see more insecurity and embarrassment among the French about not being able to speak English. I think a lot of foreigners here are frustrated when they try to speak French, the French will respond in English. So, yes, there has been a change. But unfortunately for the French, because English is the connecting language of the European Union, English instruction here is still terrible. Young elite French people often speak English well, but ordinary French people, not that well. Even a women I once dated who went to the École normale supérieure (which has a reputation similar to Harvard’s) couldn’t understand American films or television without subtitles. Macron is the first French president who can have conversations with world leaders in English.
Given that Americans who study French generally focus on reading and writing and not speaking, a conversation between an American and an ordinary French person can be a challenge. Because I’m bilingual, this is not a concern in my life, and I’m not sure if the idea of being able to speak a foreign language is different here. Maybe it is.
A curious fact. Because the growing population of French-speaking Africans, French is projected by the investment bank Natixis and others to be the most widely spoken language in the world by 2050. That might be over optimistic, but the growth is good nonetheless, because once people stop speaking French, the culture will die, as will France.
Anyway, I’m looking forward to seeing Lou play.
