It’s official - Ayanna out for the season | Page 3 | The Boneyard

It’s official - Ayanna out for the season

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dillon77

WBB Enthusiast; ND Alum, Fan
Joined
Nov 6, 2015
Messages
6,271
Reaction Score
22,358
Is there a better way to deal with orthopedic vulnerabilities? Playing less, more time in the pool less time on the floor? There was quite a lot of info on Azzi's two knee operations in high school. A compilation of players at all colleges lost for the season or longer would be helpful. Then fans would know if it's business as usual for women's college basketball or are we particularly snake bit?
Playing different sports so you don't have overuse of certain muscles/joints/tendons?

Just a perusing of headlines and I notice that a lot of these injuries affect players who are in hoops and soccer, two sports in which you can practically play year round.

Plus, there's increasing momentum to varying practices from high intensity to lower intensity and mixing up activities.

Plus, there is -- as @cancontent said, the genetic factor, which can override virtually any planning if not known.
And, of course, there are the games themselves...stuff happens, from twisted ankles to people falling and rolling into ones knees to an inadvertent elbow into someone's head.

But for now, best of luck to Ayanna with the surgery and my continued concern and prayers for Caroline's head/neck issues.
 
Joined
Jan 2, 2016
Messages
108
Reaction Score
423
Best wishes to Ayanna on speedy recovery for next season. UConn can now lock in their rotation moving forward.
Bueckers
Muhl
Arnold
Shade

Edwards
Brady
Griffin
Samuels

That is not a bad 8 player rotation going forward. UConn should be able to compete with most teams if Bueckers is the center piece.
It’s totally unfair to Ice. She is just a freshman+. Having said that she has to look in the mirror and say to herself “ready or not I’m the next woman up” That’s what really good players do.
 

Bigboote

That's big-boo-TAY
Joined
Dec 16, 2016
Messages
7,149
Reaction Score
36,465
Well that stinks on ice. I hope this surgery clears it all up.

Like many above, I've had patellar tendinitis. Mine was long-standing (poor student), but I was lucky that PT took care of it once I saw an orthopaedist. I was able to get 25 years of really good running in until arthritis put a stop to that.
 
Joined
Apr 29, 2014
Messages
2,662
Reaction Score
11,752
At some point, we need to stop accepting the 'they've been injured since High School' excuse. If that were the case, the responsible thing for the team to do would have been to deal with it last year.
The athlete has the final say, just like any patient. Would you want surgery done without your consent?!
 
Joined
Mar 28, 2023
Messages
23
Reaction Score
88
The athlete has the final say, just like any patient. Would you want surgery done without your consent?!
Is it not a trainer and coaches job to protect the athlete from themselves at times? I mean imagine all the concussions that would be played through if not...
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
2,424
Reaction Score
6,350
At some point, we need to stop accepting the 'they've been injured since High School' excuse. If that were the case, the responsible thing for the team to do would have been to deal with it last year.
Coming from someone who has none of the medical information is probably not a doctor, it is absurd for you to make such a speculation.
 

DefenseBB

Snark is always appreciated!
Joined
Nov 10, 2016
Messages
7,978
Reaction Score
29,134
If wasn’t evident before, now it is even more imperative that Geno and staff find a way to coach up Amari to contribute meaningful minutes. I mean I see other more heralded teams than ours utilizing players with lesser skills (Utah, NC State, Iowa, Texas and USC) than Amari so our highly compensated staff should be able to do something…
 
Joined
May 1, 2020
Messages
6,548
Reaction Score
19,373
4 players on bench. This team has the worst injury luck of any team, any sport, in history. At least for consecutive years.

Also, Caroline is not a question mark in my book, maybe it is "officially."

"Any team, any sport, in history"? That's a stretch.

Yes this is a bad stretch but there have been way worse that have happened to teams in the history of sport.
 

Blueballer

Transhumanist Consultant
Joined
Aug 31, 2011
Messages
5,199
Reaction Score
15,830
So she had this issue since high school .. seems like we are recruiting a lot of walking wounded out of high school ..
In every case the injuries have cropped up after we offered a scholly. Now you can be a dirtbag coach and pull back the offer after the injury (And some do) but I'm glad we don't.
 
Joined
Apr 11, 2020
Messages
2,458
Reaction Score
10,209
The bottom line is that the buck stops with the head coach.
The coach decides which recruits receive offers & which don't based on all of the information at his disposal.
The coach can influence training methods & who serves on the staff.
If fans can't pinpoint the solution then they can certainly expect the head coach to pinpoint the problem.
The team is a reflection of the head coach & their salarly is commensurate with their level of responsibilty, acumen & the expectations of the team's success rate.
To Geno's credit, at least he increased the roster size this year to help offset all of these concurrent injuries.
I disagree. I am sure Geno relies on the medical staff, the trainers, coaches, parents, and the players themselves. Yes, Geno is where the buck stops, but that doesn't mean he calls all the shots. He is not a medical doctor. Unfair to lay all of the problems the last 3 seasons on Geno. Life sometimes sucks, is that Geno's fault? You seem to think so. I am of the opinion that Geno goes to the correct lengths to protect the health of his players. (Although I would not have Paige in the game in the last 1.5 minutes when her knee buckled and fractured. Yes, a freak accident, but not an accident one ever had sitting on the bench.)
 
Joined
Apr 11, 2020
Messages
2,458
Reaction Score
10,209
OK, here's a post likely to get deleted. It might come off as sexist, but I'm a huge UConn WBB fan (wanted to say that before I get a time out). News flash: boys are different than girls. For the last 20+ years girls have been pushed, trained, and played year round just as hard, or maybe even harder than the guys. This needs to be thought out, not in college but starting around the 6th grade, or so. It has to be recognized that girls, on average and in general, are more susceptible to injuries, especially knee injuries, and coach and train them accordingly. They are not guys and never will be. Girls should not be pushed, trained, and played year round like guys. Even some guys can't handle that.

Here's my opinion. Young girls need to be carefully managed and coached through high school hopefully injury free. Allowing them to grow into mature women and stronger women in college. Pushing too early does them a huge disservice.

OK, start the rock throwing (if I'm still here).
 
Joined
Apr 29, 2014
Messages
2,662
Reaction Score
11,752
Is it not a trainer and coaches job to protect the athlete from themselves at times? I mean imagine all the concussions that would be played through if not...
A concussion is not surgery. There is a protocol that has to be followed, just as there is for virtually every injury to the bone or muscle. Surgery, though, must always remain the final decision of the patient. There are no exceptions, other than life saving procedures when someone is not conscious. I fail to understand how anyone could argue that point.
 
Joined
May 1, 2020
Messages
6,548
Reaction Score
19,373
OK, here's a post likely to get deleted. It might come off as sexist, but I'm a huge UConn WBB fan (wanted to say that before I get a time out). News flash: boys are different than girls. For the last 20+ years girls have been pushed, trained, and played year round just as hard, or maybe even harder than the guys. This needs to be thought out, not in college but starting around the 6th grade, or so. It has to be recognized that girls, on average and in general, are more susceptible to injuries, especially knee injuries, and coach and train them accordingly. They are not guys and never will be. Girls should not be pushed, trained, and played year round like guys. Even some guys can't handle that.

Here's my opinion. Young girls need to be carefully managed and coached through high school hopefully injury free. Allowing them to grow into mature women and stronger women in college. Pushing too early does them a huge disservice.

OK, start the rock throwing (if I'm still here).
In how you phrased this, you're partially correct.

It's well documented that the physical build of women makes them more prone to certain types of injuries (e.g. ACL, knee issues, etc.). No one on the board would disagree as this topic comes up for discussion every year. It's also well documented that adolescents, male and female, are over training and specializing in sports as a whole.

This isn't an issue solely in NCAAW. Look at the several of the recent NBA draft picks who have struggled to be healthy like Zion Williamson, or Chet Holmgren who blew out his knee soon after he was drafted.

Where I disagree is the tone as it comes across as if women are weaker and need to be eased into competitive sports. This is a challenge for both genders.
 
Joined
Apr 11, 2020
Messages
2,458
Reaction Score
10,209
In how you phrased this, you're partially correct.

It's well documented that the physical build of women makes them more prone to certain types of injuries (e.g. ACL, knee issues, etc.). No one on the board would disagree as this topic comes up for discussion every year. It's also well documented that adolescents, male and female, are over training and specializing in sports as a whole.

This isn't an issue solely in NCAAW. Look at the several of the recent NBA draft picks who have struggled to be healthy like Zion Williamson, or Chet Holmgren who blew out his knee soon after he was drafted.

Where I disagree is the tone as it comes across as if women are weaker and need to be eased into competitive sports. This is a challenge for both genders.
I haven't fallen through yet so lets keep stomping on the thin ice. Another shocker, women ARE weaker. No one in their right mind would suggest that it's ok for men and women to play physical, competitive sports like football basketball, soccer, hockey, etc. together. Why? Because men are bigger and stronger than women. Have you seen the videos of the UConn male practice players? They go to great lengths to avoid all contact with the women. Why is that? Of course it's to avoid injuries because the guys are bigger and stronger. I bet there's plenty of contact when it's girl on girl where the risk of injury is less.

If any of the above is true, why would you train and coach girls as if they are just like guys? Maybe they are not just like guys.
 
Joined
Jun 9, 2012
Messages
1,531
Reaction Score
4,942
If I was in charge, someone would take the fall for all of the injuries. I would have held out begrudgingly until this year when we had a lot of injuries again. It may not be fair, but something needs to change. I find it hard to believe we’ve had this much bad luck and I’m not gonna say how, but there’s one BIG way this is hurting us and it’s not losing games. You can’t keep doing the same thing and having the same results and saying everything is ok because it’s not and it’s doing damage that the program under Geno may never recover from. Someone has to make the hard decision.
 
Joined
May 1, 2020
Messages
6,548
Reaction Score
19,373
I haven't fallen through yet so lets keep stomping on the thin ice. Another shocker, women ARE weaker. No one in their right mind would suggest that it's ok for men and women to play physical, competitive sports like football basketball, soccer, hockey, etc. together. Why? Because men are bigger and stronger than women. Have you seen the videos of the UConn male practice players? They go to great lengths to avoid all contact with the women. Why is that? Of course it's to avoid injuries because the guys are bigger and stronger. I bet there's plenty of contact when it's girl on girl where the risk of injury is less.

If any of the above is true, why would you train and coach girls as if they are just like guys? Maybe they are not just like guys.

You don't but it doesn't mean girls and women can't train hard. Things may have to be done differently with respect to movement but it's totally possible. If it wasn't you wouldn't see the female athletes we do across all sports from basketball, wrestling, weightlifting, gymnastics, hockey, etc. It's totally possible.

And to your point about male practice players, I would disagree about avoiding contact. The point of male practice players is to provide the team a chance to play against more physical competition. They do not shy away from contact one bit. If male players avoided contact, what would be the point of having them in the first place? What is seen in a 30 second video is a snippet of what's actually happening.
 

HuskyNan

You Know Who
Joined
Aug 15, 2011
Messages
25,900
Reaction Score
213,557
If I was in charge, someone would take the fall for all of the injuries. I would have held out begrudgingly until this year when we had a lot of injuries again. It may not be fair, but something needs to change. I find it hard to believe we’ve had this much bad luck and I’m not gonna say how, but there’s one BIG way this is hurting us and it’s not losing games. You can’t keep doing the same thing and having the same results and saying everything is ok because it’s not and it’s doing damage that the program under Geno may never recover from. Someone has to make the hard decision.
So who takes the fall for Jana’s Achilles injury while she was playing in Europe for the Egyptian team? Should Geno have told sophomore high schooler Ayanna how to train? Azzi came to UConn with a lingering injury - is that UConn’s fault too?

5F98DFFF-EE28-4BF8-A8CD-A48280B5B199.jpeg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Online statistics

Members online
301
Guests online
1,818
Total visitors
2,119

Forum statistics

Threads
159,560
Messages
4,195,761
Members
10,066
Latest member
bardira


.
Top Bottom