The coaches you are listing are not Hurley's peers in the game. So let's look at his actual peers, the 50-and-under club with national title aspirations.
I'll only include their times at high-major schools to make it fair since no one can really hold Hurley accountable for not getting to a sweet-16 at URI... I won't include the covid year. If I miss anyone, let me know and I can add them.
Danny Hurley (50): (3 post-seasons at UConn)
Oats (48): (2 post-seasons at Bama)
Beard (50) : (5 post-seasons at Texas and Tech)
- 1 championship loss
- 1 elite 8
Shaka (45): (6 post-seasons between Texas and Marquette)
- Nothing since his miracle final-four run at VCU
Mick Cronin (50): (3 post-seasons at UCLA)
Tommy Lloyd (48): (1 post-season at Arizona)
It isn't "must win" the same way no game is technically a "must win."
But I think it's fair to say between this season and next, we need to see a sweet-16 or that seat starts getting warm. He's clearly not getting fired no matter what happens this season.