Ok, fine answer. Now, what if Gilbert gets hurt again? Will you give him another one year pass to see what he can di with a healthy team? What if Adams gets hurt? I am fine with your original hypothetical. I am just throwing out some twists to see what you would want in those slightly altered scenarios.
Basically, let's say everyone stats except Larrier, as you proposed. And, let's say, you give Ollie one more year based on that. Is he judged after that year on performance, regardless of injuries or suspensions or transfers that might occur mid-season? Or is there a scenario where you give yet another year?