- Joined
- Aug 27, 2011
- Messages
- 3,149
- Reaction Score
- 8,314
I miss this guy. Very happy he's still a big part of the program.
I'm sure there are some who would disagree, but I feel that JC left at about the right time. I think the scandals, issues, penalties, etc. (as well as his health) that plagued the team over the last 3+ years of his reign had him tired out. As a result, I don't think he was as effective in every facet the rigors of coaching required. I can't say I don't miss him as that would sound negative and I don't mean it to at all. But I love infusion of energy, youth, attitude and attention to rules and details that Ollie has brought.
It's not fair to say JC didn't care about academics, but he clearly didn't care about trying to maintain a respectable APR, with the constant stream of transfers costing us points. That negligence opened the door for Emmert's vendetta against us to play out the way it has over the past year, and JC does deserve some of the blame for that -- the ban, the negative press, and the recruiting hit in 2012 and 2013.
Looking back, he might have been better served retiring on top in 2011 or riding out the next two years for another go at it in 2014 (this upcoming year), but from this point I don't think we can complain too much about how things are looking, going forward. Let's hope the good vibes KO has injected into this program in terms of toughness, heart, and camaraderie, which have already paid some dividends on the recruiting trail, translate into on-court success in a season where expectations are higher and games are more meaningful.
JC stuck with the program through some crap times, which he should get respect for, instead of bowing out on top for legacy purposes; showed he cared about the program more than himself. He then handed it to Ollie with a 'can't lose' type of year. No matter how UConn did last year, Ollie would kind of gotten a pass. The added bonus in this smooth style transition, was that we didn't have more of the 'will JC be here by the time I leave UConn' stuff coming from recruits. Surreptitiously removed that albatross.
Well, I would argue that the timing of his retirement -- September, rather than April -- was done for egoistical purposes: he wanted to guarantee "his guy" would be the next coach. I don't think that showed he particularly cared about the program in absence of himself.
Well, I would argue that the timing of his retirement -- September, rather than April -- was done for egoistical purposes: he wanted to guarantee "his guy" would be the next coach. I don't think that showed he particularly cared about the program in absence of himself.
I agree that it worked out well for Ollie to get a trial run in a season where the W/L results didn't matter as much. And I'm also relieved to be in a better position vis a vis recruiting than we have been in several years.
I just think JC's exit could have been conducted in a more planned and less manipulative way.
Well, I would argue that the timing of his retirement -- September, rather than April -- was done for egoistical purposes: he wanted to guarantee "his guy" would be the next coach. I don't think that showed he particularly cared about the program in absence of himself.
I agree that it worked out well for Ollie to get a trial run in a season where the W/L results didn't matter as much. And I'm also relieved to be in a better position vis a vis recruiting than we have been in several years.
I just think JC's exit could have been conducted in a more planned and less manipulative way.
I don't think JC cared about the APR until he had to and was quick to show his displeasure with the Senior crew led by Edwards and company and with Sellers" recruits (one who could never get eligible anywhere), and with the stoner Jamal Coombs-McDaniel. There were other crews that fell apart--the Kirk King mess, the Wrenn Robertson era, and laptopgate Wiggins.
It was time. Finishing out the last year of BE play would have been nice. Not finishing it worked well too. With Blaney's retirement and American branding and end of the scholarship reductions and post season ban its the complete changing of the guard and end to an era. It was a good run.
JC had a weird stretch of years following the 2009 FF, which had an expected, "taking care of business" sort of feel to it in the way our runs of success with veteran teams loaded with NBA prospects usually did.
The 3-year period that followed was downright bizarre and a radical departure from the regular nature of our cycles of success and reloading that had existed for the previous 15-20 years. It included two of his worst coaching jobs, one with a leaderless veteran team, one with a leaderless young team, sandwiched around one of his best coaching jobs in getting a very young team led by a transcendent player to lock down on defense and play with the toughness required to win elimination games. My only quibble with his handling of the 2011 team is on the X's and O's side: they still never successfully ran a half-court offense, a problem which was often masked and overcome by Kemba being Kemba, and which plagued the 2010 and 2012 teams in absence of Kemba's superhuman performances.
It's not fair to say JC didn't care about academics, but he clearly didn't care about trying to maintain a respectable APR, with the constant stream of transfers costing us points. That negligence opened the door for Emmert's vendetta against us to play out the way it has over the past year, and JC does deserve some of the blame for that -- the ban, the negative press, and the recruiting hit in 2012 and 2013.
Looking back, he might have been better served retiring on top in 2011 or riding out the next two years for another go at it in 2014 (this upcoming year), but from this point I don't think we can complain too much about how things are looking, going forward. Let's hope the good vibes KO has injected into this program in terms of toughness, heart, and camaraderie, which have already paid some dividends on the recruiting trail, translate into on-court success in a season where expectations are higher and games are more meaningful.
As for 2012, there's no question in my mind that was far and away the worst coaching job of JC's career. The narrative on the 2010 team is that they were colossal under-achievers that played hard when they wanted to, but the reality is no team in the Calhoun era endured worse luck - "regression to the mean" comes to mind with that bunch. They were due for about five straight one point wins - unfortunately for the seniors on that crew, the trend didn't reverse itself until the following year. 2012, though, they were the colossal under-achievers that played hard when they wanted too - they didn't even endure the luck the 2010 squad did, they were just continually outplayed and outworked by teams with significantly less talent. I don't know if you pin the failures of the 2012 team on the inevitable championship hangover, egos, or poor coaching, but there was no excuse for that team to win less than 25 games.
Calhoun had a magical ability to instill his will onto his teams. Unfortunately, and realistically with regards to 2012, you can't turn a pack mule into a thoroughbred.