I don't get how anybody can watch these last two games and not conclude that three point shooting is this teams biggest weakness right now. With that in mind, I need to take somebody who can shoot the three at a 40%+ clip. I'd also like this player to be able to pass and defend at a high level. Adding another strong perimeter defender to the fold alongside Boatright would probably vault this defense from really good to incredible, and if we could supplement Boatright's quickness with an additional shooter and creator, it would obviously make us very difficult to guard.
To me, this narrows it down to four choices:
Caron Butler - 20 points, 8 rebounds, 3 assists, 40% from three (but only on two attempts per game)
Ben Gordon - 19 points, 5 rebounds, 5 assists, 43% from three
Ray Allen - 23 points, 7 rebounds, 3 assists, 47% from three
Shabazz Napier - 18 points, 6 rebounds, 5 assists, 41% from three
When you adjust for pace (last years UConn team played at a far slower tempo than the '96 team, for instance, leading to inflated statistics), the choice becomes obvious to me. Butler is a very appealing option due to his versatility and pure scoring ability, but perimeter shooting wasn't his forte, and we're still searching for somebody to fill the void left by Daniels and Giffey on the wing. Allen and Gordon are relatively obvious choices. Allen was superior in virtually every category aside from assists, which I value a lot on a team that struggles to pass the basketball. Neither of them were more than break-even defenders, though, and this program has always started and ended with defense.
Napier's 41% mark from three is probably slightly lower than it would have been on prior UConn teams. Last season he was obviously forced to chuck a lot of threes late in the shot cluck (which he converted in stunning efficiency), whereas Ray was predominantly a catch-and-shoot guy (though he could shoot off the dribble). Napier was a gifted floor general who rarely turned it over relative to his high usage rate.
But what makes the decision easy for me is what Napier could do defensively. Not only was he an occasionally dominant on-ball defender, he played help defense as well as I've ever seen from a UConn guard. Between him and Boatright, it was basically like playing 5 on 6 on offense for opposing teams. Go re-watch some of those games from March and tell me you don't want to see a Napier/Boatright reunion.