Always amazed at the vitriol found here at times. Calling others morons or idiots when the topic is which venue people personally find best, or loudest, or most favorable for students is puzzling to say the least. That said, I'll register my thoughts.
Until we moved away a few years ago we had season tickets in both venues from the early-80's at HCC/XL and 1990 for Gampel and we liked both for many of the reasons already stated. We were winning, games were fun and most games were sellouts. It was two hours to Gampel for us so that gave an edge to the Civic Center........at least till we became good.
Several games still stand out in my memory. St. Johns in the opening night game at Gampel in 1990 was one.
Maybe it was the circumstance of being really good for the first time, or the way a team of good players played way above their individual abilities but, to me, no game at Gampel ever matched the Syracuse and Georgetown games in Hartford in 1990. It was January of the Dream Season, we came out of nowhere at the start of the season to be a contender and beat #5 Syracuse on Big Monday and #2 Georgetown five days later.
"Electric" is often an overused cliche', but it's the only word that accurately conveys how the building felt for those two games. I can still feel how bright the lights were and how excited the crowds were, how loud the building was and, especially rare for a UConn crowd, no one left early and none of the 16,294 wanted to leave the building at the end of the games. We all stood there and roared and high fived the people around us.
Imagine, if you weren't a fan or grad or didn't attend games at the time, how the long suffering fans that trudged to games in the mid-80's felt. Always in the Wednesday night game at the Big East, always losing that game except one time, and almost feeling like we didn't belong at the Garden for the tournament.
It was so bad that we were one of only three couples that showed up for the Alumni breakfast Dee Rowe hosted one year in the mid-80's at the hotel across from the Garden (name escapes me it changed so many times) the morning after the Wednesday play-in game. We had lost again and a room that could hold 150-200 people had one table of seven talking about our love for UConn basketball. Dee was ever positive and it was great he was able to see what UConn basketball became.
And now, we're arguing and name calling about which venue is the best. Progress I guess...........