Charliebball
**
- Joined
- Jan 26, 2016
- Messages
- 13,863
- Reaction Score
- 54,081
I totally agree with your opening half about Geno being (by far) the best college coach ever. But he is stubborn and somewhat unbending. That's a significant part of his genius. On the other hand, sometimes even the geniuses need to tweak their approaches, plans, styles and strategies.
I disagree fully as MW being a good example of his making an error. Of course she's a much more skilled player than Molly or anyone on the bench after AZ but one should be asking or maybe knowing what prevented her from solidifying that slot even though it was gift wrapped for her. From my perspective that's pointing to one of Geno's greatest strengths and a primary column of the greatness of the structure of the program. She didn't earn it and deserve it and didn't get it. It's still on her! And she and only she will determine what lies ahead for her. She can show a huge sophomore jump like CD or less than that. It's hardly a given because she was HS player of the year. That will soon be a year and a half ago.
I believe his very minimal shortfall lies in the inability of developing someone to step up two years in a row and take some control of the game. AZ was clearly doing that and he sat her for almost seven minutes at the beginning of the third period.
It drives me nuts that the response to any criticism of Geno, revolves around his clearly unmatched success, so who are you to question?
When one doesn't continually question the norm or authority it leads to not only greater problems but also boredom.
Yes getting to two consecutive national semi-finals is an enormous accomplishment for any program and not many others have done it. But that's not the expectation here and that's Geno, CD and the other coaches and all of the great and not so great players who have built that. So when the NC is not reached, particularly when the last two years outcome and the flow of both those games was almost exactly the same, one should clearly analyze the how's and whys, and make those minor adjustments that that analysis indicates. What do I or anyone who comments or criticizes know?? Probably very little in comparison to Geno, CD and the other coaches but other programs are beginning to catch on and up, so you clearly don't stand still and just leave it as its been.
One needs to look around in any field of endeavor and questioning is essential to growth and further excellence.
Bronx23
there's a middle ground here...........how come Geno takes none of the blame for an underachieving bench................isn't that partly on him? As I preached all season long, suffering abuse from many Genomaniacs along the way, his inability to get more out of his bench was going to come back to haunt the team and it surely did in the loss to ND..........I won't even go into the possible impact it may have on recruiting in the future.........I'm hoping that there's none but only time will tell


