Gaffney took a big step forward tonight

[RF79]

This kid needs practice, playing time these next two games, and hopefully this can boost his confidence.

 

[Huskybass]

You’re reaction proves my point in two ways.

Age does not account for optimum performance.

Why does stating something that is a fact and not meant as a defense elicit a negative reaction in you?

Occasionally I’m surprised by a poster’s response or who responds. For example I wasn’t expecting @Doctor Hoop’s reaction. I wasn’t shocked. But he doesn’t frequently post his upset in that manner.

On the other hand I would have been disappointed had you not responded in the manner you did. In a universe of uncertainty I derive comfort in the consistency of people not being able to overcome their bad habits. For CV it’s a turnover or taking a shot he shouldn’t. For you it’s getting upset about things you can’t control and being angry if you perceive someone is defending someone or something you dislike. Just for clarity this paragraph is sarcasm.

Impress me. Be the change you insist from others. Control your emotions. See if you can avoid being upset by bad play. Disassociate emotional reaction from an event. Most importantly recognize that expression of anger and wanting payback is different than setting standards. Challenge yourself the way you challenge Alterique or CV.

Not many of us can make this type of adjustment. And yet we insist that players in stressful conditions react differently.

Believe it or not I have to challenge myself everyday to avoid the pitfalls I’m recommending you avoid. I’m not above it. Very few people who have not shut down their emotions can avoid this struggle. However the situation is hopeless if we don’t perceive what we do is negative. As I’m fond of saying in this forum we can see the faults in others but are unable to see them in ourselves.

I expect a point guard who has been with the program for 4 seasons and is 22 years old to make better decisions than a freshman. Gilbert still overpenetrates and takes bad shots, resulting in him shooting 28% through 10 games this season. 28%. That is dismal by any objective standard. For comparison purposes, Taliek Brown (who was maligned by many over his alleged inability to shoot well) never shot below .417 from the floor in any of his 4 seasons at UConn. Adams is shooting 47% as a Soph and Bouknight is shooting 58% so far as a freshman. AG is shooting 28% in large part due to poor shot selection, not a lack of capability or talent.

Gilbert plays very good D and has the capability to be a very good player and leader. He needs to realize that his role is to facilitate and take GOOD shots within the flow of the offense. It's not a talent issue with Gilbert, it's a decision making issue, and after 4 years in the program many of us expect someone with a MCDonald's All-American pedigree to not make the same mistakes over and over, especially when he is your starting point guard and has a major impact on the team's success or lack of it.

I don't see myself as negative, I see myself as realistic. Even you would have to agree that this team would be MUCH better if Gilbert and Vital exercised better judgement in terms of shot selection. That's a fair and realistic point, not a negative one.

 

[KembaStepback]

I don't see JG getting a ton of mins against conference opponents unless he improves his handle and his defense. He should be getting as many minutes as he can handle against some of these lower competition games.

Something must be going on with Gilbert. His jump shot looks worse than it has in years past. That doesn't just happen unless he's completely changing his motion or he's somehow hurt. He's been better about not forcing and while he has some bad TOs he's been a good facilitator.

The team as a whole seems to be playing really good team ball (with maybe the exception of Vital who really seems to get blinders on at times...but he's a great energy guy and teammate). I think the more this team plays the better they're going to get. If they can just find a cure for some of their cold stretches, they'll be very dangerous.

I like this team. I think it's a good sign when the freshman are showing improvement every game in some capacity.

 

[ElmCity40th]

Gaffney is a true freshman point guard. Most of his mistakes looked like pure nervousness. The kid obviously has a high level of talent and can dribble. Once the game slows down with experience, He’ll be fine.

 

[HooperScooper]

I expect a point guard who has been with the program for 4 seasons and is 22 years old to make better decisions than a freshman. Gilbert still overpenetrates and takes bad shots, resulting in him shooting 28% through 10 games this season. 28%. That is dismal by any objective standard. For comparison purposes, Taliek Brown (who was maligned by many over his alleged inability to shoot well) never shot below .417 from the floor in any of his 4 seasons at UConn. Adams is shooting 47% as a Soph and Bouknight is shooting 58% so far as a freshman. AG is shooting 28% in large part due to poor shot selection, not a lack of capability or talent.

Gilbert plays very good D and has the capability to be a very good player and leader. He needs to realize that his role is to facilitate and take GOOD shots within the flow of the offense. It's not a talent issue with Gilbert, it's a decision making issue, and after 4 years in the program many of us expect someone with a MCDonald's All-American pedigree to not make the same mistakes over and over, especially when he is your starting point guard and has a major impact on the team's success or lack of it.

I don't see myself as negative, I see myself as realistic. Even you would have to agree that this team would be MUCH better if Gilbert and Vital exercised better judgement in terms of shot selection. That's a fair and realistic point, not a negative one.

Well, look at the bright side - he has no where else to go but up! I'd bet that happens. He won't continue to shoot this badly the entire season.

 

[tennmike]

Just my opinion, but he seems mercurial. He's succeeded at the highest level before college and I suspect he will do the same here. Once he figures things out, his talent will be better displayed.

 

[Huskybass]

Just my opinion, but he seems mercurial. He's succeeded at the highest level before college and I suspect he will do the same here. Once he figures things out, his talent will be better displayed.

Hence the frustration from many of us. The talent is absolutely there. If AG facilitates, leads, and plays within himself he can become a legitimate star. I truly believe that. His upside is as solid as we could want.

 

[ClifSpliffy]

c'mon already. even dickie v pointed out the obvious. mr. gilbert almost always shoots off balance. not a recipe for success. and even if he gets a clean look in the paint, well forget that, too, since he ain't no calvin murphy, nate archibald, allen iverson, or nate robinson. if he 'grows' in self-awareness, could he pg for a top level college squad? mos' def. what's the phrase often heard here? 'stay in your lane, al.' sounds right. and, what's with his foul shooting, especially since he doesn't have to jump, or have shaq in his face?

 

[ctchamps]

I expect a point guard who has been with the program for 4 seasons and is 22 years old to make better decisions than a freshman. Gilbert still overpenetrates and takes bad shots, resulting in him shooting 28% through 10 games this season. 28%. That is dismal by any objective standard. For comparison purposes, Taliek Brown (who was maligned by many over his alleged inability to shoot well) never shot below .417 from the floor in any of his 4 seasons at UConn. Adams is shooting 47% as a Soph and Bouknight is shooting 58% so far as a freshman. AG is shooting 28% in large part due to poor shot selection, not a lack of capability or talent.

Gilbert plays very good D and has the capability to be a very good player and leader. He needs to realize that his role is to facilitate and take GOOD shots within the flow of the offense. It's not a talent issue with Gilbert, it's a decision making issue, and after 4 years in the program many of us expect someone with a MCDonald's All-American pedigree to not make the same mistakes over and over, especially when he is your starting point guard and has a major impact on the team's success or lack of it.

I don't see myself as negative, I see myself as realistic. Even you would have to agree that this team would be MUCH better if Gilbert and Vital exercised better judgement in terms of shot selection. That's a fair and realistic point, not a negative one.

The original post you directed towards me is that my statement about experience was BS.

If anything this thread about Gaffney demonstrates that experience is an important component in development along with skill and maturation.

Jalen Gaffney was a better high school player than any of the St. Peter freshman but an argument could be made he didn’t play better than any of them. Perhaps it’s the result of them getting more playing time prior to this game.

Practice is important in development but just as important is getting minutes in games.

Alterique has had 3 years beginning his senior year in high school where he was not playing competitive ball. He played last year but did a lot of adjustment in his play to avoid reinjuring his shoulder. Is it possible his shot mechanics are off because he’s readjusting once again from his last surgery?

Early in the season last year Alterique was the starting point guard but Hurley made the decision to give the majority of point guard minutes to Jalen.

You may conclude it’s bad judgment on his part for his shooting slump and his play. That’s not unreasonable. What is unreasonable is dismissing other possibilities that are equally reasonable.