Gaffney disappointing | Page 2 | The Boneyard

Gaffney disappointing

Joined
Apr 15, 2018
Messages
2,475
Reaction Score
17,776
Gaff looks good when he’s out there basically being a 2 guard. Problem is that when he comes in & RJ is there, he often has some ball handling duties to let RJ play off ball, and he struggles there. A lot
 

Chin Diesel

Power of Love
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
32,571
Reaction Score
98,523
We're 6-1. The sky's not falling.

We're 2-1. The first four were glorified scrimmages.

Each of the three games could have been a win; each could have been a loss. Made horrible decisions at end of game against each opponent. Leaving Atlantis with a bunch of question marks which need fixing to finish high in the BE and make it to second weekend of NCAAT.
 

8893

Curiouser
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
29,851
Reaction Score
96,512
I really don't understand these takes on the rotation/Hurley. Maybe he doesn't make changes fast enough for people here, but we have tons of evidence now of him integrating freshman into the rotation throughout the season. And he's been very open about how he's going to do it now that we have enough talent where they don't need to be thrown into the fire right away
It’s a very simple point: we have a glaring lack of ball handlers and shooters. Right now it appears that RJ is the only one who can do both well, but he needs help.

Many here, including Hurley, believe that AJ is the best option for that help, even though he doesn’t shoot well or have a great handle. They like the fancy passes even if they seldom result in scoring plays. Of course everyone loves the rebounds, but that still doesn’t help the shooting or handling issues. Have him play the three then, perhaps? But no way Martin is giving up his minutes on a Hurley team, nor should he at this point. So we have AJ set as our starting two guard. Do you think he is going to change that? As I said last night, I hoped so, but now I question that. It’s not like AJ was providing senior leadership out there at crunch time, which is what the ostensible reason would be for holding out the freshmen.

And they believe that Gaffney is the second-best option for that help, most evidence to the contrary now in his third season here.

I get that it’s early yet and that Hawkins and Diggins were both a little delayed by injuries, and I don’t expect them to be glued to the bench for the season; but I don’t think that the AJ experiment Is going to end as soon as you seem to expect, or that Hawkins will be able to crack the starting lineup as soon as we both had hoped.

I have no idea what it will take for Diggins to get quality minutes, but I think that will take a bit longer still.
 
Joined
May 27, 2015
Messages
13,275
Reaction Score
88,606
It’s a very simple point: we have a glaring lack of ball handlers and shooters. Right now it appears that RJ is the only one who can do both well, but he needs help.

Many here, including Hurley, believe that AJ is the best option for that help, even though he doesn’t shoot well or have a great handle. They like the fancy passes even if they seldom result in scoring plays. Of course everyone loves the rebounds, but that still doesn’t help the shooting or handling issues. Have him play the three then, perhaps? But no way Martin is giving up his minutes on a Hurley team, nor should he at this point. So we have AJ set as our starting two guard. Do you think he is going to change that? As I said last night, I hoped so, but now I question that. It’s not like AJ was providing senior leadership out there at crunch time, which is what the ostensible reason would be for holding out the freshmen.

And they believe that Gaffney is the second-best option for that help, most evidence to the contrary now in his third season here.

I get that it’s early yet and that Hawkins and Diggins were both a little delayed by injuries, and I don’t expect them to be glued to the bench for the season; but I don’t think that the AJ experiment Is going to end as soon as you seem to expect, or that Hawkins will be able to crack the starting lineup as soon as we both had hoped.

I have no idea what it will take for Diggins to get quality minutes, but I think that will take a bit longer still.
Yes, just as I told you last night there's zero reason to believe that Hawkins won't be starting by the end of December. The AJ experiment doesn't need to end for Hawkins to start, there's plenty of minutes to go around.

I think you're massively overreacting to the few games you saw in Atlantis, mid tournament is not the time to start making changes. You experiment with the next few cupcakes and figure out what works and make changes after that. It's happened every year Hurley has been here, there's no reason to think it won't happen again
 

8893

Curiouser
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
29,851
Reaction Score
96,512
Yes, just as I told you last night there's zero reason to believe that Hawkins won't be starting by the end of December. The AJ experiment doesn't need to end for Hawkins to start, there's plenty of minutes to go around.

I think you're massively overreacting to the few games you saw in Atlantis, mid tournament is not the time to start making changes. You experiment with the next few cupcakes and figure out what works and make changes after that. It's happened every year Hurley has been here, there's no reason to think it won't happen again
Who does Hawkins replace in the starting lineup then? Hurley has made it clear that he likes having AJ start because he is so “disruptive”—even if that means having an anemic offense that is in a five-to-ten point hole by the five minute mark.
 

dennismenace

ONE MORE CAST
Joined
Apr 19, 2015
Messages
3,009
Reaction Score
8,210
Stubborness is a key trait in most great and successful people across all walks of life. When others stop or quit or don't see results, the great ones see progress in the process and keep trudging along until there are results. Hurley is hardly the first coach to stay with a rotation or a player who isn't yielding results as quickly as us fans would like.

Stubborness is also a key trait in many who fail. When others see a particular choice as not being successful and not leading to success, they adapt and change while those who are stubborn keep doing the same thing expecting different results.

You become wildly successful or become the definition of insanity.

For Hurley this is where us fans have to trust assistant coaches are giving Hurley the best advice they can and the rest of Hurley's influencers are helping him through this as well.
Thank you for reminding us that he has a very capable staff and they believe in him. Most coaches believe that what happens in practice will bring out what is best in the games. I think this team got "punched in the face" (as Bruce Pearl calls it) from the start to the finish for three days in a row. As Pearl said "you come looking for this to be tested and see what you're made of meaning where your weaknesses and strengths are. Well, a lot was revealed on both counts so there is a lot of thinking, reviewing, reflecting and planning to come out of it. The team came out bloodied and overall I think they showed us something. They are going to have to have to give their all everyday
if they expect to go anywhere. I saw a lot of courage and will to win from many players. I have some fond memories of this tournament. Watching Ajax leaping like he was on a pogo stick jumping over everyone with his head above the rim (14 boards in 33 mins.), Martin showing a warrior leadership as usual and Whaley seemingly "coming back from the dead" and spearheading things at crunch time including a stanchion beatdown. I believe Gaff was overwhelmed and hope he can get back on track. I am trusting the staff can deliver on shoring up the weaknesses shown against pressure defenses one way or the other.
 
Joined
May 27, 2015
Messages
13,275
Reaction Score
88,606
Who does Hawkins replace in the starting lineup then? Hurley has made it clear that he likes having AJ start because he is so “disruptive”—even if that means having an anemic offense that is in a five-to-ten point hole by the five minute mark.
It should be Whaley, but I'd expect him to replace Jackson in the starting lineup
 
Joined
Aug 25, 2011
Messages
16,508
Reaction Score
31,975
Many of the comments are spot on but its way too early to give up on Gaff. The light bulb clicks on later for some upperclassmen. Gaffney has some tools to work with and be effective and be a strong contributor.

I expect come Conference play, Gaffney will be a contributor and vital part of our team.

I am surprised though with Hurley, and Taliek being point guards, they can't 'fix' him especially after 2+ years. More importantly, not to correct his mistakes (many the same) in-game. To me its equal blame (coaches/player).
 

Chin Diesel

Power of Love
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
32,571
Reaction Score
98,523
Odd fact most fans, myself included, probably wouldn't have guessed.

Gaff leads team in FT attempts this year and is second in FT's made.

Good or bad, he will be on the floor in end of game situations.
 
Joined
Sep 26, 2019
Messages
550
Reaction Score
2,450
I really don't understand these takes on the rotation/Hurley. Maybe he doesn't make changes fast enough for people here, but we have tons of evidence now of him integrating freshman into the rotation throughout the season. And he's been very open about how he's going to do it now that we have enough talent where they don't need to be thrown into the fire right away
It’s really just an observation, none of us are freaking out or panicking over this tournament. Overall it was a successful tournament, and Hurley and staff have been 95% great, but there is always room for an improvement in anything you do, no matter what it is.

That being said, I do believe Hurley doesn’t adapt well in games. We could have/should have won that MSU game had we adapted better. It’s going to be incredibly difficult to win games if we are playing our anemic offensive lineup of Cole-Jackson-Martin-Whaley-Sanogo for long stretches. Clearly this is the lineup that Hurley trusts the most to not make mistakes, but defenses feast on this lineup. Take a look at all the possessions where Jackson caught the ball vs MSU, the defense is literally daring him to shoot, and by playing off him that far, he has nowhere to go. He has no confidence and doesn’t even look for his shot as of right now.
The reason this got brought up in this thread is because unfortunately Gaffney is not going to be the answer, particularly against ball pressure defense, which we will get from most big east/quality opponents. Obviously Hurley knows what he has in Diggins from practice, so hopefully he was just bringing him along slowly and he will give him a good sample sized opportunity against MES and Grambling. I also think Johnson needs to get the same opportunity because he is more than likely going to give us quite a bit more than Akok, especially consistently.

One more point to address regarding Hawkins. I honestly think his handle is just fine, and his issue is more of a being sped up issue. I played basketball and sports for the majority of my life, and it’s so common to start your next move and just forget to bring the ball with you. To me it looks like that’s exactly what his issue is. He’s just going so fast and it’s causing him to lose the ball in a few instances. When you watch him take his defender off the dribble on half court offense, he has great handle and nice quick moves. This is an easily correctable thing and Hawk will be just fine imo.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
33,579
Reaction Score
96,700
Gaff looks good when he’s out there basically being a 2 guard. Problem is that when he comes in & RJ is there, he often has some ball handling duties to let RJ play off ball, and he struggles there. A lot

He didn’t look good with or without Coke in there for 3 days. He’s still the same guy we’ve seen 21/4 years in. We need him and Akok to be much better to make our depth more of an impact. For now both fall short! Hope Diggins gets play next 2, meaningful not garbage, so we can get a feel.
 
Joined
May 27, 2015
Messages
13,275
Reaction Score
88,606
It’s really just an observation, none of us are freaking out or panicking over this tournament. Overall it was a successful tournament, and Hurley and staff have been 95% great, but there is always room for an improvement in anything you do, no matter what it is.

That being said, I do believe Hurley doesn’t adapt well in games. We could have/should have won that MSU game had we adapted better. It’s going to be incredibly difficult to win games if we are playing our anemic offensive lineup of Cole-Jackson-Martin-Whaley-Sanogo for long stretches. Clearly this is the lineup that Hurley trusts the most to not make mistakes, but defenses feast on this lineup. Take a look at all the possessions where Jackson caught the ball vs MSU, the defense is literally daring him to shoot, and by playing off him that far, he has nowhere to go. He has no confidence and doesn’t even look for his shot as of right now.
The reason this got brought up in this thread is because unfortunately Gaffney is not going to be the answer, particularly against ball pressure defense, which we will get from most big east/quality opponents. Obviously Hurley knows what he has in Diggins from practice, so hopefully he was just bringing him along slowly and he will give him a good sample sized opportunity against MES and Grambling. I also think Johnson needs to get the same opportunity because he is more than likely going to give us quite a bit more than Akok, especially consistently.

One more point to address regarding Hawkins. I honestly think his handle is just fine, and his issue is more of a being sped up issue. I played basketball and sports for the majority of my life, and it’s so common to start your next move and just forget to bring the ball with you. To me it looks like that’s exactly what his issue is. He’s just going so fast and it’s causing him to lose the ball in a few instances. When you watch him take his defender off the dribble on half court offense, he has great handle and nice quick moves. This is an easily correctable thing and Hawk will be just fine imo.
I think the ball pressure defense is a bit overstated. We'll need to find the answer to beat St John's but I don't think the other teams have the rosters to pull that off against us. Doesn't mean Hurley can ignore it, but I don't think it's an issue that would derail our season.

The posts in this thread were a little more reasonable, but across threads yesterday we had people calling for transfers of just about everyone not getting minutes. That's the type of overreaction I'm talking about when I say people are being a little ridiculous
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
810
Reaction Score
3,236
Hurley has said over and over again that players earn minutes in practice. That is not going to change. If you expect Diggins and Johnson to get more meaningful minutes next 2 games you are going to be disappointed.

I think we will see Hawkins get more meaningful minutes at the expense of Ajax at the 2 guard.

Martin is gonna get 30 with Ajax filling in.

Whaley is not going anywhere. And he shouldn’t. He does too much defensively and keeps the ball moving on offense.

I can see Johnson beating out Akok in practice as season progresses.

Cole 30, Gaffney 10
Hawkins 25, Martin 10, Gaffney 5
Martin 20, Ajax 20
Whaley 15, Polley 15-20, Akok 0-5 (Johnson)
Sanogo 30, Whaley 10
 
Joined
Sep 26, 2019
Messages
550
Reaction Score
2,450
Hurley has said over and over again that players earn minutes in practice. That is not going to change. If you expect Diggins and Johnson to get more meaningful minutes next 2 games you are going to be disappointed.

I think we will see Hawkins get more meaningful minutes at the expense of Ajax at the 2 guard.

Martin is gonna get 30 with Ajax filling in.

Whaley is not going anywhere. And he shouldn’t. He does too much defensively and keeps the ball moving on offense.

I can see Johnson beating out Akok in practice as season progresses.

Cole 30, Gaffney 10
Hawkins 25, Martin 10, Gaffney 5
Martin 20, Ajax 20
Whaley 15, Polley 15-20, Akok 0-5 (Johnson)
Sanogo 30, Whaley 10
I would personally be thrilled with this, and if Diggins/Johnson show more in practice, then they eat up the Gaff and Akok/Polley minutes. But one thing is for certain, Hawk needs to be the starting sg. I don’t see it any other way here unless Jackson suddenly becomes confident and looks to actually shoot. But again, I just don’t see that happening, he passes up so so many open looks.
 
Joined
Sep 16, 2011
Messages
48,566
Reaction Score
165,772
I would personally be thrilled with this, and if Diggins/Johnson show more in practice, then they eat up the Gaff and Akok/Polley minutes. But one thing is for certain, Hawk needs to be the starting sg. I don’t see it any other way here unless Jackson suddenly becomes confident and looks to actually shoot. But again, I just don’t see that happening, he passes up so so many open looks.
I though Jackson was very aggressive offensively the past two games, his shot just didn't go down. Everything was right on he just had his shots rattle in and out.

He still makes too many mistakes but I really liked the force he played with. He was skying for rebounds and always pushing pace and looking ahead with the pass.
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
16,298
Reaction Score
24,053
14 rebounds/ 4 assists. Jackson is an essential piece. What if he drives to 15 fee, jumps about 5 feet in the air and shoots? Who is blocking him?
 
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
1,863
Reaction Score
5,894
Gaffney was horrible in Battle 4 Atlantis no doubt, but he was good before then. Keep in mind they are playing in converted ballrooms where they just lay down a floor and toss up some nets - the lighting/ceiling height/etc. isn't the same as a normal gym so it might just affect some players more than others. If he comes back and stinks over the next 5 games then I think it's time to really worry.
If he cannot be good against CCSU, LIU and Binghamton then he can't be on a BE roster, what happened in Atlantis is what the season will be, not the cupcakes he played at home before.
 
Joined
Oct 26, 2018
Messages
6,042
Reaction Score
20,399
Who does Hawkins replace in the starting lineup then? Hurley has made it clear that he likes having AJ start because he is so “disruptive”—even if that means having an anemic offense that is in a five-to-ten point hole by the five minute mark.
We have a clear top 6 that should all be averaging close to 30 mpg a game. I don’t really care who starts, Hawk just needs to play a lot more. But we don’t need to water down our rotation further we need to tighten it up. Most teams don’t give more than 7 guys significant PT and we’re not as deep as we thought.

Cole 30, Gaff 5, Jax 5
Jax 15, Hawk 25
Martin 30, Jax 10
Whaley 20, Polley 10, Akok 10
Sanogo 30, Whaley 10

30: Cole/AJ/Martin/Whaley/Sanogo
25: Hawk
10: Polley, Akok
5: Gaff
 
Joined
Sep 16, 2011
Messages
48,566
Reaction Score
165,772
We have a clear top 6 that should all be averaging close to 30 mpg a game. I don’t really care who starts, Hawk just needs to play a lot more. But we don’t need to water down our rotation further we need to tighten it up. Most teams don’t give more than 7 guys significant PT and we’re not as deep as we thought.

Cole 30, Gaff 5, Jax 5
Jax 15, Hawk 25
Martin 30, Jax 10
Whaley 20, Polley 10, Akok 10
Sanogo 30, Whaley 10

30: Cole/AJ/Martin/Whaley/Sanogo
25: Hawk
10: Polley, Akok
5: Gaff
Completely disagree.
 
Joined
Oct 26, 2018
Messages
6,042
Reaction Score
20,399
Completely disagree.
Yeah adding Diggins and Samson for an 11 man rotation will turn us into a final 4 contender…or will more minutes for gaffney, Akok and polley do the trick?
 
Joined
Sep 16, 2011
Messages
48,566
Reaction Score
165,772
Yeah adding Diggins and Samson for an 11 man rotation will turn us into a final 4 contender…or will more minutes for gaffney, Akok and polley do the trick?

Our depth needs to be used. We're not Nova. We have a bunch of good players and need to be using them. Playing 6 would be beyond stupid with this roster. Most teams don't have a 7 man rotation, you're taking out of your butt.
 
Joined
Oct 26, 2018
Messages
6,042
Reaction Score
20,399
Our depth needs to be used. We're not Nova. We have a bunch of good players and need to be using them. Playing 6 would be beyond stupid with this roster. Most teams don't have a 7 man rotation, you're taking out of your butt.
Uncalled for. I listed 8 guys playing double digit mins that’s plenty deep especially as the season goes on. We don’t have a personnel problem we have an execution problem.
 
Joined
Feb 25, 2021
Messages
343
Reaction Score
1,154
We’re gonna have a serious problem if another ball handler doesn’t step up. The blueprint is out against us. Full court pressure. Gaffney has proven he ain’t the guy and Diggins isn’t ready. Maybe we can get a transfer for the spring semester??
 

Online statistics

Members online
527
Guests online
3,130
Total visitors
3,657

Forum statistics

Threads
156,876
Messages
4,068,588
Members
9,950
Latest member
Woody69


Top Bottom