- Joined
- Aug 29, 2011
- Messages
- 4,241
- Reaction Score
- 7,177
Yankees
Ruth
Gehrig
Mantle
DiMaggio
Unassailable in my view, would have been pure recency had Jeter made it. Over whom, the Mick?!
Mets
Seaver
Wright
Hernandez
Piazza
Amazing that all but Wright played significant time elsewhere. Too bad that Strawberry & Gooden were undone by drugs otherwise I think both could have made the four. Overall struck by not that many superstars for the Mets. Franco & Gary Carter were the other two on MLB's ballot.
Red Sox
Williams
Yaz
Pedro
Ortiz
Rice, Dewey, Fisk and CY YOUNG! were on the list but didn't make the cut. Love me some big Papi, but I think I would have voted for Cy Young over him. Clemens wasn't on any ballots.
Ruth
Gehrig
Mantle
DiMaggio
Unassailable in my view, would have been pure recency had Jeter made it. Over whom, the Mick?!
Mets
Seaver
Wright
Hernandez
Piazza
Amazing that all but Wright played significant time elsewhere. Too bad that Strawberry & Gooden were undone by drugs otherwise I think both could have made the four. Overall struck by not that many superstars for the Mets. Franco & Gary Carter were the other two on MLB's ballot.
Red Sox
Williams
Yaz
Pedro
Ortiz
Rice, Dewey, Fisk and CY YOUNG! were on the list but didn't make the cut. Love me some big Papi, but I think I would have voted for Cy Young over him. Clemens wasn't on any ballots.