If Calhoun intentionally cheated, he sucked at it. We got out recruited by countless coaches at countless schools, by a LOT! Did he try to get away with everything he thought he could get away with? Yeah, probably. But if he was doing stuff he knew was going to get him in trouble, he got little to no return on that risk. Doesn't make sense. Never did. Never will.
When there is smoke surrounding a coach that is landing a ton of blue Chip players, you wonder. When that coach has little to nothing else to offer the recuits he is landing, you REALLY wonder. But when a hall of fame coach with multiple championships struggles to land one or two burger kids, he either isn't cheating or he sucks at it.