I would love for Evina to return, but she is currently projected as a top-10 draft pick and her history of injuries would strongly point to declaring for the draft now.
Yes, in fact a certain sports network recently bumped her up to #5. More important is what Geno's soliciting of GM opinions reveals. I have thoroughly enjoyed watching her play this year, would hate to see her go, but will root for her either way.
On the positive side, the breadth of her skill set is impressive. She's big enough to be a combo guard in the pros, at least overseas. She's savvy and very competitive. It appears as though her mindset throughout a game is even-keel. That said, I've never felt like she was a 1st-round pick. Her handle could use work. She is not a consistent three-point shooter. She's athletic, but not supremely quick. And frankly, in a typical game there would be two or three plays she would make/attempt that left me scratching my head. I don't know if another year of coaching could help with that.
I've felt most of the year that she was not 100%, and suspect she still is not. In my mind, her decision turns on whether her knee could get better/stronger with another year of workouts/rehab. I recognize the risks and don't wish to minimize them. Of course, you could go pro, tear a ligament in the first month and be laid up for a long time. The obverse of the knee problems being a good reason to leave is that if you anticipate such problems the rest of your career, maybe getting a good start on a master's is a good idea (probably I'm an old-fashioned idealist on that one).
One thing about this that brings out the sentimental in me is that I would hate for this perverted year to be the only one she plays at UConn. That has nothing to do with losing last night. I just think it would be great for her to play in front of thousands of adoring fans and if not get on the wall, at least go down as one of UConn's better players. That would be something she could hold onto her whole life.
Finally, Evina versus Azzi: I know a lot of posters are over the moon about Azzi. If E were to come back, I don't see Azzi (or Caroline Ducharme or Poff) supplanting E in the starting lineup. I don't see Azzi being able to rebound or defend like E, and possibly not pass like her. If I'm wrong, great. And of course, many former UConn players found some success in the pro ranks after being a sub in college.