You're absolutely right; one game analysis is silly. So why don't you compare who was better over....let's say....the last 10 years, shall we?
2011: WVU 10-3, Clemson 10-4 (WVU beats the Christ out of Clemson in the Orange)
2010: WVU 9-4, Clemson 6-7
2009: WVU 9-4, Clemson 9-5
2008: WVU 9-4, Clemson 7-6
2007: WVU 11-2, Clemson 9-4 (WVU beats OU in Fiesta)
2006: WVU 11-2, Clemson 8-5
2005: WVU 11-1, Clemson 8-4 (WVU beats Georgia in Sugar)
2004: WVU 8-4, Clemson 6-5
2003: WVU 8-5, Clemson 9-4
2002: WVU 9-4, Clemson 7-6
So essentially, Clemson finished with a better record than WVU exactly 1 time over the last ten years, with no BCS bowl victories to show for it. They also finished one of those years with a losing record, and another 3 of them only one above .500. So explain to me, sir, how on earth it is that you believe Clemson is the better football program?? Yeah, I thought so.
It's always fun when they make it easy for me...