I know very little about this, so I promise I'm not being snarky, lol.
If Cinci has a better campus and more research in their portfolio, why are they ranked way lower than UConn on the national ranking scales? Obviously they're all biased in one way or another. But they seem to generally be a reflection of what you hear about schools-ish.
I know A LOT has to do with research and the specific school, and all that. And for my fiance who is defending her PhD this summer, the "prestige" of a school in her field matters less than the advisors you can get and publishing opportunities. Rutgers is randomly like a top 5 school for some subset of her field and super-competitive to get into, even though it's not really that competitive outside of that.
US News "national colleges"
UConn - #63
Cinci - #143
Niche overall:
UConn - #158
Cinci - #171
Forbes:
Uconn - #130
Cinci - #313
WSJ
UConn - #97
Cinci - #291
There's others... but I guess you get the idea.