CBB coach Mt. Rushmore. | Page 2 | The Boneyard

CBB coach Mt. Rushmore.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Apr 2, 2023
Messages
1,727
Reaction Score
8,830
Tyler Olander has 2 more rings than Jalen Rose, so Jalen’s opinion is meaningless.
Plus Jalen Rose choked a 3-0 lead with Molly Qerim, so his judgment is suspect.
 
Joined
May 2, 2023
Messages
72
Reaction Score
417
If you're going to put Wooden on your list you'll have to recognize the Helms banners as legit as national titles
 

McLovin

Gangstas, what's up?
Joined
Dec 3, 2018
Messages
2,966
Reaction Score
18,880
If you're going to put Wooden on your list you'll have to recognize the Helms banners as legit as national titles
Why? I understand it was a different era, with less teams in the NCAA field, but it was still the “NCAA Championship”. His regular season accomplishments + the players he produced probably are good enough to qualify him for this without even taking into account his National Titles…

Also interestingly, Wooden and Calhoun’s careers overlapped with Wooden winning his final 2 titles after Calhoun started coaching at Northeastern.
 

SubbaBub

Your stupidity is ruining my country.
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
32,154
Reaction Score
24,973
Every coach that has won more than one title.

Wooden, K, JC and Smith I bumped Roy because he basically inherited Dean Smith's franchise, then I'd go with Knight over Roy for overall impact to their program and CBB. If Roy won his 3 at Kansas then he's #4.

The better question is what it you limit it to the 64+ team era >1985. K, JC, and who? Roy Williams is probably next in line here. The four isn't as obvious as none dominated for very long or without asterisks ('sup Pitino/Cal). It's probably Izzo as Donovan and Wright's peaks were much shorter. Do you pick the 'picker with Melo and the multiple final fours? (No.) If you don't require at least one championship, then are you down to Mark Few, Huggy Bear?


List of national championship wins by coach​

CoachNational titlesMost recentRunner-up finishes
John Wooden1019750
Mike Krzyzewski520154
Adolph Rupp419581
Roy Williams320173
Jim Calhoun320110
Bob Knight319870
Denny Crum219860
Billy Donovan220071
Henry Iba219461
Ed Jucker219621
Branch McCracken219530
Dean Smith219933
Phil Woolpert219560
Jay Wright220180
Rick Pitino22013*1
 

nwhoopfan

hopeless West Coast homer
Joined
Feb 16, 2017
Messages
30,037
Reaction Score
57,212
I bumped Roy because he basically inherited Dean Smith's franchise
After Guthridge and Doherty had some time to mess it up.


If Huggy and Few are gonna get mentions, I would easily put Lute Olson ahead of either of them. More Final 4's and actually won a Title.
 

FfldCntyFan

Texas: Property of UConn Men's Basketball program
Joined
Aug 25, 2011
Messages
12,990
Reaction Score
45,848
How would anyone react today if they were told URI over the next quarter century will have performed arguably as well as any school has over that time frame, have three national tiles, have spent multiple weeks in many different seasons ranked #1 with a number of elite eight and sweet sixteen appearances in years they didn't win it all? That's pretty much what the reaction in May 1986 would have been if someone predicted what we ended up accomplishing by May 2011.

Yes, every coach who has reached the heights of a national title warrants praise for the accomplishment. I just personally believe that what was accomplished by a coach that took over an established, top tier program needs to be discounted, slightly or vastly, depending on the situation, in comparison to what Jim Calhoun accomplished.

Those who weren't around (and college basketball fans) during the years before we hired Jim Calhoun cannot fully appreciate what he accomplished.
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
6,685
Reaction Score
15,533
I posted a similar thread about the Mt. RUSHMORE of CBB players last year, but this one seems like more fun.
Which 4 coaches do you put on your Mt Rushmore?

Do you go by wins and include JB and Huggins? (I know you don't, but why not?)

Do you go by stature, despite some...errr...transgressions? (B.Knight)

Or do you go by Wins, building a program and Natties? (Ummm...JC)

Obviously there are more to consider than these (Cal, Wooden, K, Dean Smith, etc.)

Have fun and play nice
Wooden, K, Smith and Calhoun.
 
Joined
Nov 11, 2018
Messages
2,057
Reaction Score
9,324
How would anyone react today if they were told URI over the next quarter century will have performed arguably as well as any school has over that time frame, have three national tiles, have spent multiple weeks in many different seasons ranked #1 with a number of elite eight and sweet sixteen appearances in years they didn't win it all? That's pretty much what the reaction in May 1986 would have been if someone predicted what we ended up accomplishing by May 2011.

Yes, every coach who has reached the heights of a national title warrants praise for the accomplishment. I just personally believe that what was accomplished by a coach that took over an established, top tier program needs to be discounted, slightly or vastly, depending on the situation, in comparison to what Jim Calhoun accomplished.

Those who weren't around (and college basketball fans) during the years before we hired Jim Calhoun cannot fully appreciate what he accomplished.
Thats a pretty cool perspective to take. My dad who graduated in '72 tells me stories about going to see games in the old field house and how janky it was. Must be weird for any uconn grad who witnessed the pre Calhoun days.
 
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
11,049
Reaction Score
17,326
It’s obviously Wooden, Calhoun, Knight and K. There are no other choices.
 
Joined
Nov 11, 2018
Messages
2,057
Reaction Score
9,324
I'd switch Kotite out for Norman Dale.
It's indicative of that team seeing how Kotite is probably the coach that comes to mind first when mentioning JETS HC's. That's who I think of immediately. Poor guy. But...a Wagner grad nonetheless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Online statistics

Members online
278
Guests online
1,585
Total visitors
1,863

Forum statistics

Threads
158,759
Messages
4,167,464
Members
10,039
Latest member
NAN24


.
Top Bottom