oldude
bamboo lover
- Joined
- Nov 15, 2016
- Messages
- 20,144
- Reaction Score
- 191,825
One of the things that we all know, but don’t always acknowledge, is that a committee of 12 human beings will ultimately seed 68 teams for the BIG Dance. The NCAA could very easily have created a computer algorithm with all the criteria deemed relevant, weighting each of those criteria however they prioritized and then simply let the computer fill in the 68 team bracket.
But the NCAA doesn’t do that. They bring a committee of individuals together, all with their own personal biases. They provide that committee with an “unweighted” list of sometimes conflicting criteria such as Body of Work, NET, late season results, impact of injuries, etc. While the committee ultimately works to a consensus, there are certainly differences of opinion. It is not all cut and dry, which is exactly why we’ve seen some head scratching seeding decisions in past seasons.
WBB seedings have been far more easily determined in prior years, particularly at the top of the brackets. But this year is different. IMO there are no less than 7 teams with a very real opportunity to win the national championship, and I would go even farther to suggest that there are up to 11 teams with a chance to win it all.
Like all of us, I am anxious to see the final seedings by the committee. I will not be surprised if there are several surprises.
But the NCAA doesn’t do that. They bring a committee of individuals together, all with their own personal biases. They provide that committee with an “unweighted” list of sometimes conflicting criteria such as Body of Work, NET, late season results, impact of injuries, etc. While the committee ultimately works to a consensus, there are certainly differences of opinion. It is not all cut and dry, which is exactly why we’ve seen some head scratching seeding decisions in past seasons.
WBB seedings have been far more easily determined in prior years, particularly at the top of the brackets. But this year is different. IMO there are no less than 7 teams with a very real opportunity to win the national championship, and I would go even farther to suggest that there are up to 11 teams with a chance to win it all.
Like all of us, I am anxious to see the final seedings by the committee. I will not be surprised if there are several surprises.