OT: - Best Pizza in CT | Page 348 | The Boneyard

OT: Best Pizza in CT

Is it time to get rid of the pizza thread?

  • Yes. It's past it's useful time here.

    Votes: 10 14.1%
  • No. I can't live without it.

    Votes: 50 70.4%
  • Move it to another board.

    Votes: 11 15.5%

  • Total voters
    71
Not Connecticut bur Treehouse Brewery makes a really nice pie. Tried Cheese and Margherita (which needed more cheese). Pepperoni looked excellent. Crisp thin crust, perfectly cooked. Not my picture. Dave P gave it a 7.9. I tried at the Sandwich location.

1730287682211.jpeg
 
There's a place called PaPa's Tomatio Pies in Robbinsville, New Jersey that is known for their Mustard Pizza. We tried, against my reservations as a staunch Sally's fanatic. It shouldn't work, but somehow, it did. The tangy flavor surprisingly meshed with the dough and sauce. I'm reasonably persuaded to try it again.
PaPa's Tomato Pies
 
There's a place called PaPa's Tomatio Pies in Robbinsville, New Jersey that is known for their Mustard Pizza. We tried, against my reservations as a staunch Sally's fanatic. It shouldn't work, but somehow, it did. The tangy flavor surprisingly meshed with the dough and sauce. I'm reasonably persuaded to try it again.
PaPa's Tomato Pies

Delorenzos is better in my opinion but can't go wrong with either!
 
There's a place called PaPa's Tomatio Pies in Robbinsville, New Jersey that is known for their Mustard Pizza. We tried, against my reservations as a staunch Sally's fanatic. It shouldn't work, but somehow, it did. The tangy flavor surprisingly meshed with the dough and sauce. I'm reasonably persuaded to try it again.
PaPa's Tomato Pies


Papa’s is solid. Need to try DeLorenzo’s nearby and DeLucia’s.
 
Delorenzos is better in my opinion but can't go wrong with either!
Papa’s is solid. Need to try DeLorenzo’s nearby and DeLucia’s.
There are two De Lorenzo's Pizza in the area. One in Robbinsville (De Lorenzo's, De Lorenzo's Tomato Pies Est. 1947) that I particularly like and find they come close-ish to Sally's with the char while the other is in Hamilton (DeLorenzo's, Pizza Restaurant | Private Event Space | Trenton, NJ | DeLorenzo's Pizza) and is also very good. Haven't decided yet which one has the better anchovy pizza. They are separate entities but related by blood (similar to Sally's and Pepe's). There's Conte's Pizza in Princeton is another joint that is quite good, and I've conversed with the elder staff in Italian.
 
There's a place called PaPa's Tomatio Pies in Robbinsville, New Jersey that is known for their Mustard Pizza. We tried, against my reservations as a staunch Sally's fanatic. It shouldn't work, but somehow, it did. The tangy flavor surprisingly meshed with the dough and sauce. I'm reasonably persuaded to try it again.
PaPa's Tomato Pies

I love Papas and Iove that this thread just randomly pops up out of nowhere every once in a while.
 
I've got money on Pepe's in New Haven but what do you all think?
Other than its clam pizza, Pepe’s is overrated. In New Haven, I prefer Modern. In greater New Haven, Bobby’s on Rte 80 in North Branford has been, and remains, my go-to for 38 years, even though I have lived in Farmington for the past twelve.
 
Not Connecticut bur Treehouse Brewery makes a really nice pie. Tried Cheese and Margherita (which needed more cheese). Pepperoni looked excellent. Crisp thin crust, perfectly cooked. Not my picture. Dave P gave it a 7.9. I tried at the Sandwich location.

View attachment 104471
Treehouse Brewery also makes a pretty good beer to compliment the pretty good Pizza!
 
Treehouse Brewery also makes a pretty good beer to compliment the pretty good Pizza!
A couple of years ago, I heard that Treehouse was going to open a stand at the Patriots stadium in Foxboro. Did they?
 
If this is true, that's a lotta pie, and those Ivy Leaguers are pretty smart...



Trenton does the pie bass ackwards with the meat and cheese on the dough and then the sauce as the last topping, right? That's really a Chicago deep dish. But does Trenton do it deep dish or do they do it regular crust?

New Haven style pizza is great. Not my favorite, but I like it. I've not heard anything that suggests NJ is at the forefront of innovation in pizza cuisine. What am I missing?
 
I don't know how that's even possible. How many ovens do they have?
I have no idea. Maybe they made the pies during the game and then reheated them somehow at a Yale dorm or something. Or they just ate the pizzas cold.
 
I have no idea. Maybe they made the pies during the game and then reheated them somehow at a Yale dorm or something. Or they just ate the pizzas cold.

My guess is they banged out the pizzas during the game and delivered them in shifts to the locker room where there was a series of heat lamps setup.

It's absolutely possible to bang out a few hundred pizzas in a few hours (flashbacks to the late 80s when I made (and delivered) pizzas for Dominos. The output could get insane.
 
Trenton does the pie bass ackwards with the meat and cheese on the dough and then the sauce as the last topping, right? That's really a Chicago deep dish. But does Trenton do it deep dish or do they do it regular crust?
I grew up 30-40 minutes away from Trenton, and I’ve never heard of that “style” until today. Looking into it, it doesn’t seem like Chicago style that has that thick layer of sauce on top; rather, dollops of sauce around the pie, not unlike how you see dollops of ricotta

I doubt anyone daid NJ is on the forefront of pizza creativity; that’s probably New York, as CT seems pretty set in their ways, and New York is a top 5 worldwide food city. I believe the argument is that there is tons and tons of good pizza in the state to where one could reasonably argue it’s the best state.
 
Trenton does the pie bass ackwards with the meat and cheese on the dough and then the sauce as the last topping, right? That's really a Chicago deep dish. But does Trenton do it deep dish or do they do it regular crust?

New Haven style pizza is great. Not my favorite, but I like it. I've not heard anything that suggests NJ is at the forefront of innovation in pizza cuisine. What am I missing?
Trenton's acknowledged top two taste very good.

In February 2023, I visited Papa's and DeLorenzo's, both in suburban Robbinsville, NJ, just outside Trenton, relocated from the city in response to historical shifts in neighborhood demographics & appeal.

They are not down the street from each other as Frank Pepe and Sally's are, (but they are within a mile), and their fans compete with each other in claiming which is better. I liked both very much.

I like my favorites in the New Haven area more, but I would comfortably include the two Robbinsville places among my Top 25 if they were within the radius extending from Fairfield to Cheshire to Clinton with New Haven at its center.

As with most mind, body, and mood-altering substances, set & setting plays a very important part in what is best for each person on the particular day & circumstances that surround the partaking, so exact ranking is a moving target I'll avoid that here.

The 5 places listed in post 8282 above as a tour itinerary is the best such geographically-efficient grouping for such a purpose that I have seen.

It is an unparalleled embarrassment of riches to have so many 'go to' options in Connecticut.
 
Last edited:
If this is true, that's a lotta pie, and those Ivy Leaguers are pretty smart...


Don’t think there’s ever been a debate about CT vs. NJ pizza. CT vs NY maybe, but not NJ.

Wrong again. Is UConn in the Big 12 yet?
 

Online statistics

Members online
199
Guests online
1,522
Total visitors
1,721

Forum statistics

Threads
163,969
Messages
4,376,966
Members
10,168
Latest member
CTFan142


.
..
Top Bottom