Banners? | Page 2 | The Boneyard

Banners?

JonathanXIV said:
No one said it was false. They are saying it's embarrassing and in bad taste.
Expand ...

It could only be “embarrassing “ to SCar. Nobody else can be embarrassed by it.

uconn fans can feel contemptuous about it but not “embarrassed.”

we get it. We ain’t UConn. Not even close. But it’s our banner
 
I like Dawn. She's a fine coach. She has built a strong program, including an enthusiastic and loyal fan base.

With those disclaimers in place, she has veered into excessive hucksterism, I suppose in an effort to rouse her players and fans. If it works for them, ok.
From here, it looks a little silly.
 
visitingcock said:
It could only be “embarrassing “ to SCar. Nobody else can be embarrassed by it.

uconn fans can feel contemptuous about it but not “embarrassed.”

we get it. We ain’t UConn. Not even close. But it’s our banner
Expand ...

Yes, fans of WCBB can be embarrassed by it. And if S Carolina isn’t embarrassed by it, it says something about the program.
 
Here's my issue with South Carolina's "unanimous #1" banner (other than it is factually inaccurate). It's not just a South Carolina issue as, by definition, it claims a "championship" over every other program. If South Carolina wants to put up a banner for it's program best 29 game win streak, have at it.

To use a UConn example, lots of people were upset when UConn worked with Villanova so that Sales could have the all-time (at the time) UConn scoring record. Since that only involved a UConn record I thought it was a UConn matter, and had no impact on any other program. I would not have felt the same way if the record involved was a NCAA record. Feel the same way about S. Carolina. Since they are "claiming" a NCAA "championship" of sorts, I think they are overstepping.
 
You know, basketball is a funny sport. You actually have to win on the court. Polls, opinions, etc. don't count. For instance, has there ever been an upset in basketball? That's my point.
 
This is what a program does when it wants to validate itself and not be validated by others. Poor choice in my mind.

It brings to mind all of the banners hanging above Lynah Rink at Cornell. National Championships, Regular Season championships and league (playoff) championships and two retired jersey's. Those are the rules. Cornell was #1 in the final NCAA polls when the season was ended for them. Guess what...no banner
 
visitingcock said:
Please point out any falsity in the banner
Expand ...
Well, since you asked, they received “26 of 30” in one poll and “26 of 32” in another. How is that “ unanimous”? One other thing that stood out as a bit ridiculous imo was the statement that they (SC) chose not to claim the national championship. In what world do programs choose whether they are national champions? Look, with all due respect, (and Dawn deserves some respect for what she has built there), this is just embarrassing! Instead of enhancing her status as the architect of one of the elite programs this kind of silliness detracts from it. Why not list an imaginary score for each (imagined) opponent they think they would have played in the tournament? That would look good on the banner. I’m breathlessly waiting for Boston’s Final’s MOP banner to go up as well!
 
Hey. I have no problem with what Coach Dawn and her athletic department did with the banner. Coach Neighbors (Arkansas) talked about celebrating successes and how some people were critical of him and his team celebrating winning 2-3 games in a row, when he first got to Arkansas, like they won a title or something. Just something to build on. Pretty sure Coach Staley is doing the same thing with her program.
 
I suppose in Dawn's world she has declared General P. G. T. Beauregard the winner too. Where is that banner?
 
Kaizen said:
Massey has Oregon as 2019-2020 #1. So where is Dawn's "Unanimous # 1 ?
Expand ...
Maybe they mean the AP and Coaches Poll so that both polls were unanimous in who they were ranking #1 heading into the Tournament.

Now if the writers knew this was a FINAL POLL, would they have voted differently? Also, the NCAA came out and stated they wouldn't have a champion nor would they take a "Final Vote" so that's where Dawn's illogic shines supreme...no one supports her view.

To all the "upset Gamecock fans", yes we respect what Dawn has achieved but we do not condone "awarding" unearned accolades, so if you are upset with our views, perhaps you should go vent on Cockytalk or whatever that forum is, as you will not find any sympathy here.
 
Last edited:
visitingcock said:
Please point out any falsity in the banner
Expand ...
No attack but that should be evident to anyone that can read and has been pointed out above multiple times.
JonathanXIV said:
Bingo...
Expand ...
It could only be “embarrassing “ to SCar. Nobody else can be embarrassed by it.

Again NO ATTACK personally but I can see where some who cherish the women's game finding it a step below honorable. The wording could have reflected a great season with out being misleading. Banners are simply recruiting tools and wow factors for new fans that should have a trophy to match JMHO.

With all due respect for Dawn and all she has achieved, leading a team at a institution of higher education, this was not well thought out or worded. As for embarrassment should be only to SCar, one must be remiss to the fact she is the head coach of USA basketball.
With her drive and toughness one would find it hard to believe she has succumbed to the everyone gets a trophy generation.
 
vowelguy said:
I believe "unanimous" refers to the fact they were #1 in all the polls (AP, Coaches). [Massey isnt a poll.]

It's tricky - I can understand the desire to want to recognize a team that was #1 and didnt get a chance to compete for the title through no fault of its own. Bitter pill.

At least they didn't declare themselves National Champ.

FWIW, I dont think anyone was going to come close against Oregon.
Expand ...
I'd disagree in that most people who see unanimous think it means everyone. Not 64 voters of varying degree of knowledge and loyalty. Notice how the word polls was omitted from the banner. I'm sure it was just a lack of banner space. :rolleyes:
 
Alydar said:
I'd disagree in that most people who see unanimous think it means everyone. Not 64 voters of varying degree of knowledge and loyalty. Notice how the word polls was omitted from the banner. I'm sure it was just a lack of banner space. :rolleyes:
Expand ...
I think of it from college football where in the pre-playoff days, a "unanimous" #1 was the #1 in both major polls, as opposed to a disputed/split poll situation.
 
browns said:
Yesterday South Carolina unveiled a banner that read "Unanimous # 1 2019-2020" up on their rafters. I guess that's what you do when you only have 1 NC. Dawn continues to be adamant that they should be declared National Champions.Personally I think Oregon would have won it all if the tourney had been played but your thoughts on hanging a banner like that
Expand ...
I remember when the Gamecocks came to Storrs ranked #1. We wacked them by 25. I would also venture that if UConn hadn't been shocked by MissSt a few years back, SC would never have won a NC. In that championship year, the Gamecocks lost to the Huskies on their home court by 18.
I like Dawn personally (though a lot of top talent has gone through Columbia and won zilch), but her banner reminds me of another possibility: "SC: Where Quality is a Slogan."
 
vowelguy said:
I think of it from college football where in the pre-playoff days, a "unanimous" #1 was the #1 in both major polls, as opposed to a disputed/split poll situation.
Expand ...

You remember that far back? I do too and when it said unanimous No 1 it meant you got all the 1st place votes. I remember a true unanimous No 1 in 2013. I haven't looked at their wall but I don't think Mulkey thinks they won anything.
 
Alydar said:
You remember that far back? I do too and when it said unanimous No 1 it meant you got all the 1st place votes. I remember a true unanimous No 1 in 2013. I haven't looked at their wall but I don't think Mulkey thinks they won anything.
Expand ...
No idea what you are talking about nor what Mulkey has to do with college football.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Online statistics

Members online
175
Guests online
1,066
Total visitors
1,241
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Share This Page

Forum statistics

Threads
164,045
Messages
4,380,236
Members
10,172
Latest member
mangers


.
..
Top Bottom