It is much deeper than that.
Someone who is an achiever, someone who aspires to considerable heights, someone who needs to continually prove to himself that he can accomplish great things would have said to himself "if we can reach these attendance levels today, in 20-25 years we can sell out a 75k seat stadium!". Hathaway instead saw that the Rent was filled and said to himself "No need to do any work here, the job is already done.".
Before anyone tries to blame any current employee of the University of Connecticut they need to take a better look at what was thrown away. Day one at the Rent should not have been our peak.