AA announcements [merged thread]

[Aluminny69]

Are you suggesting because she is the best player on her team, that she deserves first team All-American? What about the best player on Quinnipiac? What about the best player on the University of Hartford? A pretty big first team of All-Americans, isn't it? It's the 5 best players in the country and I and others don't feel she is! It's true, I'm not a fan but that doesn't change the fact that there are other players that don't get her exposure who are better players. There are players that you and I haven't ever seen that potentially could be better than she is, don't you agree?

You need to read vowelguy's post again. "Wilson is the best player, by far, on a team that has a #1 seed." Note the qualifier. That limits it to only four teams.

 

[RockyMTblue2]

She will/might be.

Real conundrum isn't it; course, so is she and that's on her and dad. I would not want her on my WNBA team.

 

[Vowelguy]

Are you suggesting because she is the best player on her team, that she deserves first team All-American? Are you assuming that one of the criteria for first team All-American is that you have to play on a Number 1 seeded team?

I said none of these things. I merely responded to the OP.

The OP said that Gabby contributes more to her team's success than Wilson does to hers. Gabby is one of 3 great players on a great team. Wilson is the best player by far on a very good team. Simple math suggests it is unlikely that Gabby is more responsible for her team's success.

Whether that should be the criteria for AA is not the issue at hand, and I have made no comment either way on that.

 

[Vowelguy]

You need to read vowelguy's post again. "Wilson is the best player, by far, on a team that has a #1 seed." Note the qualifier. That limits it to only four teams.

Not that it matters, but the highlighted phrase is a mere descriptor. Ie, "Wilson is the best player on a team (South Carolina) that has a #1 seed."

 

[RogueDave]

Pheesa and Lou are a couple of the best players in the country...Gabby is the best player on the team...Saniya and Kia we wouldn't be a great team without...IDK...I heard some Italian guy said something like that one time...