Ollie was not going to put all his eggs in one basket on Carey and went forward with the Akinjo and Matthews commits. Boeheim gambled last year with his PG recruiting and missed out on Quade Green and had nothing left for PG recruits and ended up w/ a 3-star combo guard. Syracuse will be hurting at PG again this year even if they stay healthy. Boeheim did the same this year with everything focused on Carey and it will likely payoff this year. Whether Carey is successful at PG is to be determined.
Boeheim traditionally casts a much smaller recruiting net. Ollie, because of the less glamorous AAC schedule and a couple of mediocre seasons, casts a much broader net with more offers. Ollie's previous issue was that while he would cast a bigger net, he would still focus on just the big fish. That approach seems to have changed after getting burned with Diallo, MAL and likely others. Waiting on Carey may have pushed Akinjo and/or Matthews elsewhere. Waiting on Shittu would have pushed Kisunas elsewhere.
If either Shittu or Carey decided that UConn is their destination a scholarship would be found. But if a guard is looking for playing time and sees Gilbert, Akinjo, Vital, vs. Frank Howard and Howard Washington, Syracuse would have to be the favorite by far.