2023 Giants | Page 15 | The Boneyard

2023 Giants

They all suck no need to stick with narratives this team sucks, the line sucks Devito isn’t good and yes I’ll say it Saquon hasn’t looked good either.
I think we have seen the last of Barkley. Again, Offensive line didn't help. Oh and the play calling. I think you have to agree it has been suspect. The opposing defensive coordinator does not have a hard job scouting the Giants. Third and one. Guess who. Barkley. Every time.
 
It is time for Bobby Johnson to go. there is a clear issue on the line and looking at Feliciano's numbers in SF (0 sacks, 10 pressures, 97.0 pass blocking efficiency and 87.7 run grade) after his far from stellar year at NYG its clear to me we do not have a talent issue, rather a coaching issue, on the line. Neal has not progressed. JMS looked awful on Sunday. Besides Thomas its a complete disaster. I take it back tho we do also have a talent issue but that is compounded by the lack of development and coaching the line gets from BJ. Please please fire him and bring someone in who can finally build us a reputable line.
 
I think we have seen the last of Barkley. Again, Offensive line didn't help. Oh and the play calling. I think you have to agree it has been suspect. The opposing defensive coordinator does not have a hard job scouting the Giants. Third and one. Guess who. Barkley. Every time.
I don't think Barkley should been given a long term deal, I think its dumb to do it for any RB not named McCaffery, and I trust mnagement believes the same. If he is given one it will only be because of Mara.

With that said Barkley has not been given much of a chance this year with Jones out. Teams have 0 respect for TD or TT to beat them down the field:

Saquon Barkley w/ Giants QB’s:

W/ Daniel Jones (42% stacked boxes)
Stacked box: 19/55 2.9 YPC
Light box: 26/149 5.7 YPC

W/ Tyrod Taylor (60% stacked boxes)
Stacked box: 27/91 3.4 YPC
Light box: 18/80 4.4 YPC

W/ Tommy Devito (69% stacked boxes)
Stacked box: 47/223 4.7 YPC
Light box: 21/72 3.4 YPC

The fact TD and TT are putting up the putrid numbers they are with those kind of coverage is laughable.
 
Played tough. Hosed by refs on the false start and no call on obvious pi. Hurts is just too tough. Schedule is a joke, why play twice in 3 weeks?

Also last play Robinson pushed out of bounds well before the ball got there by Blankenship, Daboll was crazed. The boys hung in there made the a-wipe Eagle fans and Sirianni nervous and that’s fine!
 
.-.
Happy with the game today - a good loss!!
I agree. Defense stepped up Taylor did very well. Phillys run game was tough. What was his name Swift? Eagles tired out out defense wuth the run. Not bad. Covering the spread at their hous.
 
We showed some grit on both sides of the ball. Figuring out what’s good with this team is important in these games. We know what’s bad!! Don’t lose the top 5 draft pick in the process.
 
Two biggest question marks are Jones and Neal. I think we draft Jones replacement at 1 and Neal’s with one of the number 2s
 
Lotta credit to Daboll and the coaching staff in general. This team has improved a good amount over the course of the year and has played hard week in week out despite a myriad of injuries.

Tyrod could have had 400 yards today if guys caught the ball.

They are not a good football team but they are much closer to the middle of the pack then they are to the Panthers, Patriots, Washington, ect.
 
.-.
I am very concerned they are going to win Sunday.
Eagles are actually playing for something and after a loss to Arizona I don't think they'll slip up again. Giants have to somehow end up with a top 3 pick on Sunday and I'll be happy
 
Eagles are actually playing for something and after a loss to Arizona I don't think they'll slip up again. Giants have to somehow end up with a top 3 pick on Sunday and I'll be happy
What are the scenarios for that to happen? Haven’t been looking really.
 
Eagles are actually playing for something and after a loss to Arizona I don't think they'll slip up again. Giants have to somehow end up with a top 3 pick on Sunday and I'll be happy
Only playing with something if Dallas losses, I am worried with Howell back at QB in Washington Sirani sees its 17-3 Dallas at half and he begins pulling guys. He has complained about the turf at Metlife before and I am sure he'd like to avoid an injuries.
 
What are the scenarios for that to happen? Haven’t been looking really.
There's a bunch of strength of schedule factors that are too hard to calculate but their range is 2-8 right now. Could get as high as 2 if Washington, New England, Arizona all win and the SOS for the Giants remains lower than all 3 (right now it is). Likely outcome is probably them staying at 5
 
There's a bunch of strength of schedule factors that are too hard to calculate but their range is 2-8 right now. Could get as high as 2 if Washington, New England, Arizona all win and the SOS for the Giants remains lower than all 3 (right now it is). Likely outcome is probably them staying at 5
To get to 2 they need to lose, Washington win, NE win, Arizona win, and then 3 of these 4: Pitt win, Bears wins, Denver win, Colts win. The latter is for SOS vs. NE.

But don't 100% hold me to this ha.
 
.-.
I am very concerned they are going to win Sunday.
With Tyrod definetly, he’s in a good rhythm and Eagles secondary sucks, Devito looked like he was shell shocked against the Eagles. I hate this feeling where you really wanna beat the Eagles but you know it’s best that the Giants lose this game.
 
I know I should want a loss but it's fun to beat the Eagles
Especially in this fashion the Eagles have quit pulling Hurts and their lineman. Giants should run up the score on them, need to shut them out. Btw there is now no difference in draft position.
 
Especially in this fashion the Eagles have quit pulling Hurts and their lineman. Giants should run up the score on them, need to shut them out. Btw there is now no difference in draft position.
Right now that's not true, could swing from 4 with a loss to 7 with a win.

Could though stay at 5 either way
 
The win cost 1 spot, will draft 6th now.

Nice to see them beat Philly. Eagles look terrible.
 
.-.
End up at 6, should be in a good position to get a weapon for Daniel Jones now with a WR like Nabers
 
I don't think they have a QB on the roster that can get them to the playoffs again
 
I don't think they have a QB on the roster that can get them to the playoffs again
Despite the fact they have a QB on the roster who not only got them to the playoffs, but won a playoff game 11 months ago
With an o line they may have two QBs good enough
Tyrod is not under contract for next season
 
Despite the fact they have a QB on the roster who not only got them to the playoffs, but won a playoff game 11 months ago

Tyrod is not under contract for next season

I know Jones got them there, and won a game...that's why I said "again". I just don't think he's good enough to do it again...
 
.-.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,543
Messages
4,581,550
Members
10,491
Latest member
7774Forever


Top Bottom