triaddukefan
Tobacco Road Gastronomer
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 21,367
- Reaction Score
- 68,552
Minus Well get this started.
I think Daneesha Provo of Utah played the same number of games as Tudor last year (13), so maybe the difference was that Provo also had a short season as a freshman at Clemson before transferring?Bummer about Tudor. The NCAA has been getting generous about granting another year of eligibility if you transferred mid season at some point in your career. But since Tudor has stayed at the same school, no go.
I think Daneesha Provo of Utah played the same number of games as Tudor last year (13), so maybe the difference was that Provo also had a short season as a freshman at Clemson before transferring?
Also, I'm wondering if Tudor might have had better luck with her waiver request if she's waited until after this season to apply for it. Especially if she misses a significant chunk at the start of the season while she finishes rehabbing.
Can she reapply for the MRW after this season in view of "limited competition" for a second consecutive season?
The biggest takeaway for me was the fact that Minyon Moore looked like she had been with the team for a very long time--same speed to the basket and intensity on defense, but also some really terrific passing, and a much improved outside shot ((2/3 from 3, I think). She will make a difference.
Destiny Littleton denied her waiver for South Carolina. She had been seeking immediate eligibility due to "personal reasons."
hailstate.com
Speaking of Littleton, I did a double take when I saw her photo on the twitter post:
Wow does she look like a different person. Dropped a ton of weight and looks in great shape.
Speaking of Littleton, I did a double take when I saw her photo on the twitter post:
Wow does she look like a different person. Dropped a ton of weight and looks in great shape.
South Carolina was not a top 10 team last year.Having to fight to survive on a consistent top 10 team will do that to you.
South Carolina was not a top 10 team last year.
Hopefully this was tongue in cheek. However if not, then you misunderstood the post. Since at least the end of the 2013-2014 season they have finished in the top ten. Last season they were in a rebuilding mold after losing A Wilson and still finished 13. They are preseason back in the top 10 this year. Having a single rebuilding season doesn’t change the expectation of the program or that they have been consistently in the top 10. If it trends downward then obviously that changes things.South Carolina was not a top 10 team last year.
Two different things there. One is a medical redshirt the other is a transfer waiver request.Bummer about Tudor. The NCAA has been getting generous about granting another year of eligibility if you transferred mid season at some point in your career. But since Tudor has stayed at the same school, no go.
Maybe he meant the last 5 years combined?
Two different things there. One is a medical redshirt the other is a transfer waiver request.
Tudor denial of a medical redshirt was predictable because it did not meet this medical redshirt guideline:
"The student-athlete must not have competed in more than 30% of the season or three contests, whichever is greater."
Tudor got hurt against Washington State on Jan 4 during OSU 13th game of the season. Oregon State played in 34 games last season. Tudor would only have been able to play in 11 games to be eligible for a medical redshirt. These are pretty clear long standing guidelines and I'm not sure how OSU could have missed them.
You keep mixing up your apples, coconuts, and bananas and there is nothing magical or strange about it. Daneesha Provo withdrew from Clemson in January of 2015 for personal reasons. This is/was not a Medical Redshirt situation. Whatever those personal reasons were she either did not apply for or was not granted a waiver to be immediately eligible when she transferred to Utah because she sat out the 2015-16 season at Utah and played the following three season. At the completion of the 18-19 season her 5 year clock would have expired and her 4 years of eligibility (1 at Clemson & 3 at Utah) "should" have expired. The NCAA didn't go to her and say you can play another year. She went to the NCAA with a petition for an extra year of eligibility and an extension of her 5 year clock. Whatever her personal reason were for withdrawing from school was probably enough for the NCAA to approve her petition.See Daneesha Provo from Utah. She also played in 13 games, exact same number as Tudor, in what was her Sr. year. However because she played in 12 games at Clemson during her Fr. year the NCAA magically gave her another year of eligibility. It's strange to wait more than 2 years to retroactively grant her additional eligibility due to her transfer. But she played in more than 30% of 2 different seasons, plus 2 full seasons. NCAA violates its own rules.
You keep mixing up your apples, coconuts, and bananas and there is nothing magical or strange about it. Daneesha Provo withdrew from Clemson in January of 2015 for personal reasons. This is/was not a Medical Redshirt situation. Whatever those personal reasons were she either did not apply for or was not granted a waiver to be immediately eligible when she transferred to Utah because she sat out the 2015-16 season at Utah and played the following three season. At the completion of the 18-19 season her 5 year clock would have expired and her 4 years of eligibility (1 at Clemson & 3 at Utah) "should" have expired. The NCAA didn't go to her and say you can play another year. She went to the NCAA with a petition for an extra year of eligibility and an extension of her 5 year clock. Whatever her personal reason were for withdrawing from school was probably enough for the NCAA to approve her petition.
Utah's release on Provo said, "She was awarded an additional season based on limited competition in two of her four seasons along with extenuating circumstances beyond her control." That makes me think that "limited competition" in only one season is a less compelling scenario for the NCAA to grant a waiver.Meh. She played in 12 games. Maybe she had a good reason for leaving Clemson, but she shouldn't get another full season after that. I can't imagine that it wasn't a combination of 2 partial seasons that swung the NCAA's decision in her favor. Once you start granting exceptions for some players, it's completely unfair to players who don't get exceptions.