Funny thing is, I missed that game. I was following live stats at a random softball field. I just remember waiting to see if Dyson's FTs showed up as makes in regulation when we were down two, and then waiting and waiting to see the clock show 0:00 when we were up 1 in OT - and instead I got SD +2.
The step back over Sticks was part of a larger philosophical point I made at the time. Going with big 6-8 or 6-9 guys at the 3 made it harder for us to defend three guard lineups. Back to back appearances, we had George Mason going at Gay in OT on a key bucket, and San Diego going at Sticks. Gay defended GM and Sticks defended SD about as well as you could hope, but smaller, quicker guards were able to change direction and get separation. So I've remembered that game a little more just for that (we weren't going anywhere without AJP anyway).
I can't tell you much about Iowa State in 2012, which I did see, other than that we got rolled early and Roscoe shot from midcourt with six seconds left in the half to make the same mistake twice. There weren't any other details worth remembering.