Women’s AP All-American Team | Page 2 | The Boneyard

Women’s AP All-American Team

HuskyNan

You Know Who
Joined
Aug 15, 2011
Messages
25,898
Reaction Score
213,515
Is the wall for those that have exceptional careers or just for popular players?
It’s for first team All-Americans. A player’s number isn’t retired until she’s inducted into the Hall of Fame
 
Joined
Mar 3, 2015
Messages
908
Reaction Score
6,915
Can't disagree with any selection except Reese. Her attitude does not represent 1st Team All-American.
 
Joined
Nov 24, 2011
Messages
7,518
Reaction Score
24,552
Congrats to all of the players who made the All-American Team. Huge shout out to our beloved Aaliyah Edwards. Well-deserved honor. I was watching some games from last year and remembering some of the comments folks made about Aaliyah. Like I said, well deserved honor Aaliyah. Super proud of you and all of your hard work. Keep up the great work. Again, congratulations to all of the players who made the list.
 
Joined
Feb 4, 2016
Messages
657
Reaction Score
2,475
In fairness to players...they should designate 25 players with no team designation. Everything else is top "25". I mean the letters "TN" make me itch, but come on...no Jackson or Horston? Latson. Taiyanna Jackson. Mikesell. Celeste Taylor. You get my point.
I agree, as far as Horston is concerned. I’d swap out Reese from first team and replace her with Kitley. Cooke on the 3rd team? Maybe HM at best, too inconsistent.
 
Joined
Mar 31, 2021
Messages
798
Reaction Score
4,007
Her play does though.
Not exactly.
If you enter an allowance horse in race against low priced claiming horses the allowance horse will win the majority, if not all, of the races. When you enter that same allowance horse in a race against Grade 1 or Grade 2 Stakes winners that horse will lose.

Angel Reese’s scoring average against all “competition” this year: 23.4 ppg
Angel Reese’s scoring against Grade 1 competition: 16 ppg
Angel Reese’s rebounds against all “completion” this year: 15.5 rpg
Angel Reese’s rebounds against Grade 1 completion this year: 4 defensive rebounds (zero offensive rebounds) per game.

South Carolina was the only Graded Stakes winner LSU faced all year.

IMHO her play does not qualify her as a first team All American. Perhaps second team based upon the fact that the voters usually weigh how many points the player scores as the most important metric.
 

Carnac

That venerable sage from the west
Joined
Jan 9, 2015
Messages
15,931
Reaction Score
79,000
First team - South Carolina's Aliyah Boston is a three-time AP All-American. Iowa’s Caitlin Clark, Villanova’s Maddy Siegrist, LSU’s Angel Reese and Indiana’s Mackenzie Holmes. Boston and Clark were unanimous choices by the 28-member national media panel that votes in the AP Top 25 each week.

 
Joined
Mar 21, 2021
Messages
2,838
Reaction Score
13,133
Not exactly.
If you enter an allowance horse in race against low priced claiming horses the allowance horse will win the majority, if not all, of the races. When you enter that same allowance horse in a race against Grade 1 or Grade 2 Stakes winners that horse will lose.

Angel Reese’s scoring average against all “competition” this year: 23.4 ppg
Angel Reese’s scoring against Grade 1 competition: 16 ppg
Angel Reese’s rebounds against all “completion” this year: 15.5 rpg
Angel Reese’s rebounds against Grade 1 completion this year: 4 defensive rebounds (zero offensive rebounds) per game.

South Carolina was the only Graded Stakes winner LSU faced all year.

IMHO her play does not qualify her as a first team All American. Perhaps second team based upon the fact that the voters usually weigh how many points the player scores as the most important metric.
The grade 1 sample size is just too small. That's not Reese's problem. It's on Mulkey. Look. Is LSU a bit overrated? Yes. Is Reese? No.
 
Joined
Aug 8, 2013
Messages
2,867
Reaction Score
15,204
Can someone repost the requirements for getting on the wall? I know I saw it years ago but have for……what was I saying…gotten. I guess third team doesn’t do it? Never mind!
 
Joined
Nov 8, 2021
Messages
1,780
Reaction Score
8,954
Tough competition on this list. 15 solidified candidates. Call me a homer if you want. Aliyah should be second team and Lou should be third team.
You think Aliyah Boston should be second team?
 

MilfordHusky

Voice of Reason
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
37,430
Reaction Score
127,682
Carl has more details:

 
Joined
Dec 12, 2018
Messages
608
Reaction Score
3,376
Because the Huskies were not a top four team in the polls for most of the season, the individual players didn't get the National notice. Hope that provides a lot of motivation during this NCAA run. It looks like only four Big East players made this list?
That's a nice little nugget. I Didn't recognize 4 Big East players made it.
 
Joined
Mar 31, 2021
Messages
798
Reaction Score
4,007
The grade 1 sample size is just too small. That's not Reese's problem. It's on Mulkey. Look. Is LSU a bit overrated? Yes. Is Reese? No.
I agree that it would better to have a greater sample size. But whom else to include? I considered including Tennessee in the “Graded” category. But their performance throughout the year was inconsistent. If Tamari Key was available I probably would have included them because they would have been more consistent. But a 6’6” post would not have helped Angel’s numbers.
The point I was trying to make was that strength of schedule should be taken into consideration in the All American voting. Individual stats get padded from the 3 digit blowouts against the weaker teams even when playing time is reduced. And if LSU ate a little beef jerky instead of just cup cakes Angel’s stats would be more in line with the second and third team selections.
 
Joined
Jan 24, 2022
Messages
1,738
Reaction Score
17,958
Can someone repost the requirements for getting on the wall? I know I saw it years ago but have for……what was I saying…gotten. I guess third team doesn’t do it? Never mind!
Be apart of the 10-person WBCA All-American team.

 

Sakibomb25

Yamasaki Let the Good Times Roll
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
301
Reaction Score
1,129
She just hasn't gotten better since her Sophomore year. Her and Fran Belibi have such high ceilings but seem to have gotten stuck on the third floor.
I think one of the problems with Jones is she doesn’t have a certain position in which she can really focus on. The saying ‘Jack of all trades, master of none’ sort of applies here, imho. She is amazing, don’t get me wrong, and I wouldn’t trade her for anyone else, but perhaps this is the reason she hasn’t increased her numbers significantly. But hey, what do I know?
 

Online statistics

Members online
476
Guests online
2,469
Total visitors
2,945

Forum statistics

Threads
159,554
Messages
4,195,576
Members
10,066
Latest member
bardira


.
Top Bottom