If I'm Shoni I'm honored that the fans chose me but embarrassed around my teammates and other team players. The fact a "rookie" sub was voted in is really ridiculous. I can name so many other deserving players but at least Bentley should be in there instead of Shoni. I guess Atlanta and ESPN did enough hype to get her an enormous amount of votes. To me that is embarrassing to the WNBA. One day she will be a terrific player but she needs to be a more consistant starter before she would get my vote as one of the top two guards in the conference.
Remember, the All-Star game is a popularity contest - if you want to know who is "first team WNBA" you have to wait to the end of the season.
I also don't see blaming this one on ESPN - not that I have been watching much, but it looked to me from the voting that Atlanta, along with Phoenix and Minnesota, did get a bit of the vote out (including players not in the top 5 vote getters) more so than other franchises. Interesting that they are also the more successful franchises this season.
In any case, Shoni has her own following and if she is that popular, good for her. Catchings hardly would deserve it if it wasn't a popularity / respect contest, since she only played 2 games to that point as well.
It isn't embarrassing to the WNBA at all, any more than the All-Star game is a "real" game.