McAfee looks like a bigger (slower?) version of Washington. I think in 2 years he and Washington will be battling for the starting job. I've been one of Shirreffs biggest defenders, not because he's great, but because he was our only viable option, and he was still an improvement over Boyle, Whitmer, and everyone else cleared to play.
That said, I think it's Pindell's job to lose. Only ----ing Diaco would bring in a JUCO QB who didn't even provide depth at QB and move him to FB (Anderson).
Pindell will have to put in the work, do/say the right things, but the plan is likely to start him this fall and have Shirreffs there as a backup. Redshirt every other QB that hasn't already.
If Washington or the Antivirus come in competing as true freshman, then they are incredible talents. I expect to see one of them in 2019.