I haven't read all three pages of this thread, so apologies if I'm repeating what someone else said.....
the biggest difference re: talent/recruiting classes is that under RE and his staff, players developed and greatly improved during their time here. Under PP/GDL (and apparently BD) there appears to be very little improvement/development over the years. RE's recruiting classes were in the same ballpark as the last 5-6 years, or even worse, but by the time his kids were juniors/seniors the majority of them were playing at the same or greater levels than those higher rated recruits who went else where. That has rarely happened the past 6 seasons, it's more of an exception when it does happen. RE's gift was projecting how good a player would be in 2-3 years, and then coaching them up to reach their potential... PP/BD and their staffs lack that