Noah is a good one. I agree - I thought he was just an energy guy in college who didn't have the skill set needed in the NBA. He's carved out a nice career.
Carmelo Anthony - to be fair, I always automatically deduct a few points from all Syracuse players in the draft not just because they're Syracuse guys (although I'm sure watching UCONN contain him well 3 times his FR year doesn't help!), but because of the 2-3 zone and how that background never transitions well to the NBA. I underestimated his ability to draw fouls with the level of consistency that he did in college. I didn't think he'd flop out of the NBA like most Cuse players do, but I also didn't think he'd become a superstar either.
Andre Drummond - I saw absolutely NOTHING in his year at UCONN, aside from athleticism on a few dunks, that showed me that he had a post-up game or could handle big players on defense. It's early, but he has definitely found his game in the NBA.